Re-considering zip-off convertible pants

[Stephan the Painter]

I've avoided zip-off convertible pants because I found them uncomfortable. But the idea behind them is so useful, I'm reconsidering.

On me, they chafe where the zipper is. I don't have especially thick thighs, so I'm not sure why it bothers me. I'm wondering if other users here have specific brand suggestions or comments.

I'm interested in something with at least a couple of cargo pockets. I tried some Columbia brand ones that I returned. Also, a couple higher end brands whose name I don't remember that I tried on at the local outfitter.... all irritated me.

The last time I was traveling when the weather got too hot for me, I ended up hacking off the legs of one of my pants to create shorts!

 

[SeñorJacques]

I had the same problem as you when I was gearing up for my CF in 2022. I thought I'd settled on a pair of Columbia convertible pants, but the material felt uncomfortable and the fit was too shapeless.

I ended up buying a pair of Prana Stretch Zion pants and they were the perfect choice. They're not exactly zip-off convertible pants: instead, they have snaps at the bottom of each leg so you can roll up the pants from the ankle to just below the knee and keep them secured. Having the extra ventilation on my calves when things got too warm proved to be just the ticket. (They're also discreetly ventilated in the inseam gusset, which is a feature I wish all hiking pants would have.) The understated cargo pocket was the perfect size to fit my credential and passport, so I always had them on me instead of having to worry about keeping them in a seperate bag, and there's a "hidden" zippered coin pocket as well which fits some emergency cash/cards or even a minimalist wallet.

Stretch Zion™ Pant II | prAna

This ReZion™ style has everything you could ever need for the journey. Discover the Men's Stretch Zion Pant II. Shop Now

www.prana.com

The fabric is soft and has just the right amount of stretch., And perhaps best of all - they're nicely tailored and don't scream "long distance hiking pants", which meant I could wear them in the cities I visited after my walk without looking too unkempt. They're not the cheapest pants, but I still wear the pair I bought almost two years after my walk so I've gotten a good amount of use from the initial investment. And you can get 20% off your first order when you sign up on the Prana website.

 

[Stephan the Painter]

I had the same problem as you when I was gearing up for my CF in 2022. I thought I'd settled on a pair of Columbia convertible pants, but the material felt uncomfortable and the fit was too shapeless.

I ended up buying a pair of Prana Stretch Zion pants and they were the perfect choice.

Thanks, I'll take a look. And I agree, those zip offs are unfortunate when you're trying to look a little nicer.
I have a Prana sweater that I scored at a thrift shop which is absolutely my favorite sweater.

 

[SeñorJacques]

One more thing about the Prana pants: They come in two fits, regular and "slim". I'm not exactly "slim" (34"-36" waist), but the slim version fit me better and looks more flattering. If there's an REI in your neck of the woods, you can probably try on both and see which one you like better.

 

[bprohs]

I've avoided zip-off convertible pants because I found them uncomfortable. But the idea behind them is so useful, I'm reconsidering.

On me, they chafe where the zipper is. I don't have especially thick thighs, so I'm not sure why it bothers me. I'm wondering if other users here have specific brand suggestions or comments.

I'm interested in something with at least a couple of cargo pockets. I tried some Columbia brand ones that I returned. Also, a couple higher end brands whose name I don't remember that I tried on at the local outfitter.... all irritated me.

The last time I was traveling when the weather got too hot for me, I ended up hacking off the legs of one of my pants to create shorts!

I’ve had Columbia zip offs in the past and didn’t care for them. I bought a pair of Kuhl zip offs and just spent 20 days in Columbia hiking all over the place. I like them so much I’m thinking about buying a second pair. They aren’t the easiest to attach the legs while you’re wearing the shorts part, but I got better with time. One other thing, they were extremely comfortable and I never even knew I was wearing convertible pants.

 

[J Willhaus]

Yes, maybe try on some different brands?

 

[Stephan the Painter]

I bought a pair of Kuhl zip offs and just spent 20 days in Columbia hiking all over the place. I like them so much I’m thinking about buying a second pair. They aren’t the easiest to attach the legs while you’re wearing the shorts part, but I got better with time. One other thing, they were extremely comfortable and I never even knew I was wearing convertible pants.

Thanks, I'll take a look.

 

[Tony Walsh]

I use the same. They work a treat

 

[Stephan the Painter]

I use the same. They work a treat

Thanks. Do you mean the Kuhl's or the Pranas?

 

[TrvlDad1]

I have three pair of REI "cargo" pants with zip-offs that I rotate for hiking. They have abundant pockets and are quick-dry. I usually take two pair on Camino. Not a favorite of the fashion police, but work for me. Never had the irritation issue.

 

[Dave2525]

I had a pair similar to these Eddie Bauer Ascent. By mid-morning it was warm enough so that I unzipped them until the next day. No comfort problems.

 

[markie6]

I take a normal pair of hiking trousers ( pants to some others) by Craghoppers, good enuff for Palin to circumnavigate the globe and also a pair of shorts with decent sized pockets. I can make better trade offs with regard to weight carried elsewhere in my pack.

In the same respect I wouldn't take trousers / pants that are lined. I would take some long johns with my normal trousers and remove when too hot, add when too cold.

 

[J F Gregory]

I am cheap when purchasing hiking clothes. I live in the Cascade mountains and have trails outside my door. I do most of my shopping at Bass Pro Shop. I buy Redhead brand zip offs $39.00 and have worn then on 3 Caminos plus walks in Other nations. I only have had 3 pair in the last 7 years.

 

[OCHAR]

I find that items that are designed to do two things, usually do them half as well.
Stretch denim (Jeans) pants and a separate stretch denim shorts have served me the best. Lots of pockets. They are available in a variety of colors too.

 

[Anthony18]

I had the same problem as you when I was gearing up for my CF in 2022. I thought I'd settled on a pair of Columbia convertible pants, but the material felt uncomfortable and the fit was too shapeless.

I ended up buying a pair of Prana Stretch Zion pants and they were the perfect choice. They're not exactly zip-off convertible pants: instead, they have snaps at the bottom of each leg so you can roll up the pants from the ankle to just below the knee and keep them secured. Having the extra ventilation on my calves when things got too warm proved to be just the ticket. (They're also discreetly ventilated in the inseam gusset, which is a feature I wish all hiking pants would have.) The understated cargo pocket was the perfect size to fit my credential and passport, so I always had them on me instead of having to worry about keeping them in a seperate bag, and there's a "hidden" zippered coin pocket as well which fits some emergency cash/cards or even a minimalist wallet.

Stretch Zion™ Pant II | prAna

This ReZion™ style has everything you could ever need for the journey. Discover the Men's Stretch Zion Pant II. Shop Now

www.prana.com

The fabric is soft and has just the right amount of stretch., And perhaps best of all - they're nicely tailored and don't scream "long distance hiking pants", which meant I could wear them in the cities I visited after my walk without looking too unkempt. They're not the cheapest pants, but I still wear the pair I bought almost two years after my walk so I've gotten a good amount of use from the initial investment. And you can get 20% off your first order when you sign up on the Prana website.

Señor Jacques, are the Prana Stretch Zion pants quick dry?

 

[t2andreo]

I've avoided zip-off convertible pants because I found them uncomfortable. But the idea behind them is so useful, I'm reconsidering.

On me, they chafe where the zipper is. I don't have especially thick thighs, so I'm not sure why it bothers me. I'm wondering if other users here have specific brand suggestions or comments.

I'm interested in something with at least a couple of cargo pockets. I tried some Columbia brand ones that I returned. Also, a couple higher end brands whose name I don't remember that I tried on at the local outfitter.... all irritated me.

The last time I was traveling when the weather got too hot for me, I ended up hacking off the legs of one of my pants to create shorts!

REI sell a line called the Sahara convertible cargo pant. I have used them on all six of my Caminos. They are made of 100 nylon, are windproof, and even if soaking wet (from rain) usually dry enough to wear in about 30 minutes.

More importantly, and to your concern, the zipper seam falls at a good place on my lower thigh, above the knee. There is no chafing. I have chunky, muscular, not fat legs.

I wear one pair, and pack a second pair. That gives me FOUR pairs of pants - two shorts and two long. They are very light and fold very small - to fit in a one gallon ziplock bag while riding at the bottom of my rucksack.

Given that you live in Maine, USA, you should have access to an REI - somewhere.

Hope, this helps.

 

[geot]

Given that you live in Maine, USA, you should have access to an REI - somewhere.

There's a store in Westbrook, just outside of Portland. That's a bit of a drive from Rockland admittedly.

 

[Joynz]

I've avoided zip-off convertible pants because I found them uncomfortable. But the idea behind them is so useful, I'm reconsidering.

On me, they chafe where the zipper is. I don't have especially thick thighs, so I'm not sure why it bothers me. I'm wondering if other users here have specific brand suggestions or comments.

I'm interested in something with at least a couple of cargo pockets. I tried some Columbia brand ones that I returned. Also, a couple higher end brands whose name I don't remember that I tried on at the local outfitter.... all irritated me.

The last time I was traveling when the weather got too hot for me, I ended up hacking off the legs of one of my pants to create shorts!

I have considered but never purchased zip offs because the zip seam is always stiff and would be annoying. Also, (more important) I like long pants for the sun protection! I have Marmot pants that roll up about 25cm with a tab to secure. But for the Camino I just wore standard hiking pants (Australian brand Mountain designs or an old Macpac pair).

On a seperate note, I discovered that my nylon slightly stretchy hiking pants with are much ‘hotter’ in hot weather than my Macpac non-stretch nylon hiking pants. Really noticed this when I travelled to Egypt after my Camino.

 

[SeñorJacques]

Señor Jacques, are the Prana Stretch Zion pants quick dry?

Yes, in that the fabric is lightweight and doesn't seem to absiorb that much water to begin with. I've definitely put them on damp out of the washing machine when I don't have time for or access to a dryer.

 

[SoulDesire]

I like zip-offs, but noticed something disturbing with my pair of Cape zip-offs (with upf30+ feature). When my legs get a little damp from sweat, the pants grab/stick over the knee when I lift my leg up, like when stepping over a rock, or on steps, so I have to grab both pants legs and lift to allow free leg movement. I must look like a woman with those long dresses who has to hold her dress up on stairs so she doesn't trip on it. I don't know if this is because of the sun-protection treatment, or the material, which is standard stuff - moisture wicking and quick dry.
I have two other different brand zip-offs but haven't noticed this problem.

 

[Jarrad]

Zip-offs: I'm a big fan. I brought two pair of North Face zip-offs on the Camino. Love them. I would have been fine leaving the lower legs of one pair at home. Only complaint was one pair really shrunk after a stint in the dryer.

I am also a fan of Kuhl and used a pair (Renegade Convertible is the name on the tag) last year on the TMB. I really like them. Good fit, good construction, and very comfortable. My son gave me a pair of Pranas. They look mighty stylish, but haven't had the chance to try them out hiking yet. Wore them around the house and I do like the stretchy aspect to them. I have some from Columbia and I do not like them for hiking. I wear them fishing and that's about it.

In 2016 I used a very thin pair from Mountain Hardware on a backpacking trip in New Mexico. They were outstanding and I think would be ideal for a June-August Camino.

 

[Lindsay53]

I am not a fan of zip off pants. Apart from the chafing they are a pain to convert from one to the other. Far easier to have separate shorts and long pants.

 

[AussieSunnygirl]

I have no issues at all with my Kathmandu zip-off pants. Wore them in CF 2022 and will be taking them again this year; might even buy a second pair as they’re so handy and comfy. Kathmandu is a New Zealand brand which I believe also owns Macpac, purchased in Australia - recommend them, cant fault them. .

 

[natcire]

i got 3 pairs of convertibles from Costco, they were like $18 a pair. The material is not as soft as Kuhl or REI's but am still wearing them after 5.5 years. My fav pair got bleached lighter from meseta sunlight, the bottom half was stowed in pack so it retained the original color. i still wear them together. I have thought of mixing colored legs but have not gone that far yet, not yet. I don't mind mixing colored socks but pant legs...hmmm.

 

[Jephyr]

I’ve had Columbia zip offs in the past and didn’t care for them. I bought a pair of Kuhl zip offs and just spent 20 days in Columbia hiking all over the place. I like them so much I’m thinking about buying a second pair. They aren’t the easiest to attach the legs while you’re wearing the shorts part, but I got better with time. One other thing, they were extremely comfortable and I never even knew I was wearing convertible pants.

Agree, used Kuhl zip offs for 2023 CF. Quick drying if/when wet.

 

[SilentNight]

Concur, Kuhl is comfortable, cool looking, and with an excellent fit, compared to the several brands of convertible pants that I bought over the years at REI. Kuhl zippers have bothered me the least. Kuhl has a fabric liner on the inside of the convertible pants’ zipper, which keeps the zipper away from your skin. (See photos of my husband’s pants.) My husband liked my Kuhl pants so much, he bought two of his own. I only ask him not to wear the same color as my Kuhl pants when we travel. For adventures in chilly weather, I love my Kuhl frost pants (not convertible).

 

[David Tallan]

I've avoided zip-off convertible pants because I found them uncomfortable. But the idea behind them is so useful, I'm reconsidering.

On me, they chafe where the zipper is. I don't have especially thick thighs, so I'm not sure why it bothers me. I'm wondering if other users here have specific brand suggestions or comments.

I'm interested in something with at least a couple of cargo pockets. I tried some Columbia brand ones that I returned. Also, a couple higher end brands whose name I don't remember that I tried on at the local outfitter.... all irritated me.

The last time I was traveling when the weather got too hot for me, I ended up hacking off the legs of one of my pants to create shorts!

I have worn Columbia brand ones on every Camino I've done since I started doing Caminos again. I'm not sure if they are the same brand as the ones you used. My son, who walked the 2016 Camino with me really liked them, too. I would go and check which model they were. I'd go and check but I am out of town, visiting with my sister after some hospitalero training over the weekend. When I get back home later this week I can check.

 

[Stephan the Painter]

Concur, Kuhl is comfortable, cool looking, and with an excellent fit, compared to the several brands of convertible pants that I bought over the years at REI. Kuhl zippers have bothered me the least. Kuhl has a fabric liner on the inside of the convertible pants’ zipper, which keeps the zipper away from your skin. (See photos of my husband’s pants.)

Thanks for posting the photos. Lots of KUHL zip-off fans around here. But they are sure not giving them away, are they?

 

[backpack45]

I used to always wear the zip-offs and never felt the zipper connection was uncomfortable, but I have sort of drifted away from wearing them. Now I tend to take other long pants as well as hiking skirt that falls just above the knee.

 

[Camino Chrissy]

I never really cared for zip off pants, although I love the concept. They were always baggy and although the feel of the zipper itself did not bother me, it was more their stiffness I felt that was annoying as I walked. Possibly the Kuhl brand are a bit more slim fitting and hopefully zippers are more supple than they have been in the past, which has been nearly ten years since I've owned a pair.

 

[CWBuff]

make it +1 for the zip-off convertibles fans. I hiked Machu Picchu in a pair and ultimately bought me 2 pairs (dif colors) for the Camino - which is what I used. The brand is Mountain Club; seems now-a-days you can find them on eBay.... I personally had no issues once so ever and was and still am very happy. They are getting somewhat beat up by know.... i figure they will still make the planned July TMB and may have to be retired after that so I'll be on a lookout form new pair(s)

 

[ShellToucher]

I've avoided zip-off convertible pants because I found them uncomfortable. But the idea behind them is so useful, I'm reconsidering.

On me, they chafe where the zipper is. I don't have especially thick thighs, so I'm not sure why it bothers me. I'm wondering if other users here have specific brand suggestions or comments.

I'm interested in something with at least a couple of cargo pockets. I tried some Columbia brand ones that I returned. Also, a couple higher end brands whose name I don't remember that I tried on at the local outfitter.... all irritated me.

The last time I was traveling when the weather got too hot for me, I ended up hacking off the legs of one of my pants to create shorts!

Check out the Cresta Pants from LL Bean! Having tried and tested a variety of brands I find them to be the best on 2 Caminos. They also have an inner flap liner that covers the zipper teeth inside the pants to prevent rubbing. I actually just did a deep dive into these pants in a recent video on my youtube channel if you are interested! Oh and here is a photo of the zipper flap!
Buen Camino!

 

[dbier]

Since my Columbia's fit fine while walking, but cut off my "chunky" thighs while sitting, I too will be looking for an alternative for next year.

 

[Peterexpatkiwi]

Another zip off fan. One pair of Columbias is 20 years old and paper thin, I keep waiting for them to rip - but they just keep on going. Super light, dry fast, and whilst I don’t love the zip, nor does it bother me.
Got my new pair last winter in a clearance sale, should have bought two - but then, that was before I became a Camino addict…..

 

[Camino Chrissy]

Got my new pair last winter in a clearance sale, should have bought two - but then, that was before I became a Camino addict…..

 

[David Tallan]

I have worn Columbia brand ones on every Camino I've done since I started doing Caminos again. I'm not sure if they are the same brand as the ones you used. My son, who walked the 2016 Camino with me really liked them, too. I would go and check which model they were. I'd go and check but I am out of town, visiting with my sister after some hospitalero training over the weekend. When I get back home later this week I can check.

Of course, they don't say which model, but looking at the website, I'm pretty sure they are Silver Ridge. I've got pretty chunky thighs. I can't count the number of "lifetime guarantee" Tilley pants I wore through in the thighs as a result when I was still wearing them. But I haven't had any problems with these Columbias, either with them being tight or wearing through.

 

[KDub]

I never liked my zip-off pants before, but I got a new pair from Columbia last year and they are really nice. Much better quality than the ones I got from Academy sports store. Otherwise I usually hike in my Eddie Bauer trousers.

 

[Jensjaunt]

I've avoided zip-off convertible pants because I found them uncomfortable. But the idea behind them is so useful, I'm reconsidering.

On me, they chafe where the zipper is. I don't have especially thick thighs, so I'm not sure why it bothers me. I'm wondering if other users here have specific brand suggestions or comments.

I'm interested in something with at least a couple of cargo pockets. I tried some Columbia brand ones that I returned. Also, a couple higher end brands whose name I don't remember that I tried on at the local outfitter.... all irritated me.

The last time I was traveling when the weather got too hot for me, I ended up hacking off the legs of one of my pants to create shorts!

Hi Stephen - you might want to explore OR ( Outdoor Research) clothing. Some of the zip off pants had the zip overtop of fabric so to not touch your legs.

 

[henrythedog]

I’m watching the thread with interest as I’ve never been happy with zip-offs, considering them to be both unsatisfactory trousers and unsatisfactory shorts, but I’m prepared to try again

Having not robbed a bank recently I doubt I’ll be trying Prana or Kuhl!

 

[DBC]

I've avoided zip-off convertible pants because I found them uncomfortable. But the idea behind them is so useful, I'm reconsidering.

On me, they chafe where the zipper is. I don't have especially thick thighs, so I'm not sure why it bothers me. I'm wondering if other users here have specific brand suggestions or comments.

I'm interested in something with at least a couple of cargo pockets. I tried some Columbia brand ones that I returned. Also, a couple higher end brands whose name I don't remember that I tried on at the local outfitter.... all irritated me.

The last time I was traveling when the weather got too hot for me, I ended up hacking off the legs of one of my pants to create shorts!

I took 2 pairs of North Face zip-offs. They will soften up every time you wash them. Never use any fabric softener or tumble drier cloths. It stops them wicking moisture effectively.
Fit is a personal choice - I had a pair of 38” and a pair of 36”. On very hot days the baggier pair were cooler.

 

[Bothydave]

I have big muscly legs and have worn Craghopper Kiwi trousers for years in the warmer months both zip off and non zip off. Very quick drying and if new surprisingly water resistan. All are windfroof and bomb proof As well as insect proof.
wore a pair of zip offs on Camino in 2022.they are so voluminous that I never felt any drag in the zip area. I only took the legs off on 2 days so really the non zip offs would have been fine. It is what you find comfortable that works

 

[TexasIndia]

I've avoided zip-off convertible pants because I found them uncomfortable. But the idea behind them is so useful, I'm reconsidering.

On me, they chafe where the zipper is. I don't have especially thick thighs, so I'm not sure why it bothers me. I'm wondering if other users here have specific brand suggestions or comments.

I'm interested in something with at least a couple of cargo pockets. I tried some Columbia brand ones that I returned. Also, a couple higher end brands whose name I don't remember that I tried on at the local outfitter.... all irritated me.

The last time I was traveling when the weather got too hot for me, I ended up hacking off the legs of one of my pants to create shorts!

I felt the same as you. However, this last October I needed to save some weight and my REI zipoffs were the solution. It ended up being cold and rainy so I wore them as long pants almost exclusively. They worked well. They were lightweight and no rubbing or chafing. I was happy to have them.

 

[CA_Pilgrim]

I've avoided zip-off convertible pants because I found them uncomfortable. But the idea behind them is so useful, I'm reconsidering.

On me, they chafe where the zipper is. I don't have especially thick thighs, so I'm not sure why it bothers me. I'm wondering if other users here have specific brand suggestions or comments.

I'm interested in something with at least a couple of cargo pockets. I tried some Columbia brand ones that I returned. Also, a couple higher end brands whose name I don't remember that I tried on at the local outfitter.... all irritated me.

The last time I was traveling when the weather got too hot for me, I ended up hacking off the legs of one of my pants to create shorts!

The only hiking pants I wear are REI Sahara Convertible Pants (https://www.rei.com/product/202030/rei-co-op-sahara-convertible-pants-mens)

I have no chafing problems with the zippers and they are lightweight and dry in a flash. I like that they have 6 pockets (4 in the front and 2 in the back). Since I only wear this brand of hiking pants, the pockets get assigned for certain things, so I always know where they are located (e.g., key pocket, wallet pocket, passport pocket, trash pocket, etc.). They come in a variety of colors.

 

[t2andreo]

There's a store in Westbrook, just outside of Portland. That's a bit of a drive from Rockland admittedly.

Try ordering online. Size up, per my experience.

Also, I found that the best colors were grey and olive green. They handle the grime and dirt better, and color match with virtually everything.

I wear one pair of these cargo pants on the flight over, with my hiking boots, and pack the other pair in my rucksack (in a ziplock bag). I will typically wear one pair for a week, then switch and wash the first pair.

If the lower leg sections get muddy or dirty, zip them off and rinse or wash in any convenient water source. I have used fuentes (fountains), rain barrels, and even a stream once. Once you wring them out, they air dry in about 30 minutes. THAT is why I love these pants.

Hope this helps.

 

[Bob Gauthier]

I’ve had Columbia zip offs in the past and didn’t care for them. I bought a pair of Kuhl zip offs and just spent 20 days in Columbia hiking all over the place. I like them so much I’m thinking about buying a second pair. They aren’t the easiest to attach the legs while you’re wearing the shorts part, but I got better with time. One other thing, they were extremely comfortable and I never even knew I was wearing convertible pants.

Totally agree, they are worth the money.

 

[Hikoi]

I have no issues at all with my Kathmandu zip-off pants. Wore them in CF 2022 and will be taking them again this year; might even buy a second pair as they’re so handy and comfy. Kathmandu is a New Zealand brand which I believe also owns Macpac, purchased in Australia - recommend them, cant fault them. .

No, they’re competitors.

 

[Hikoi]

I tramp (hike for non-Kiwis) in shorts. I took two pairs of identical zip off pants but only one set of zip off bottoms and just zipped them on on cold evenings. The brand was McKinley, which I bought online. The only thing was the pockets were a little shallow.

 

[Stephan the Painter]

If the lower leg sections get muddy or dirty, zip them off and rinse or wash in any convenient water source. I have used fuentes (fountains), rain barrels, and even a stream once. Once you wring them out, they air dry in about 30 minutes. THAT is why I love these pants.

That's definitely one of the handiest things about them.

 

[DwainS]

I have worn Columbia brand ones on every Camino I've done since I started doing Caminos again. I'm not sure if they are the same brand as the ones you used. My son, who walked the 2016 Camino with me really liked them, too. I would go and check which model they were. I'd go and check but I am out of town, visiting with my sister after some hospitalero training over the weekend. When I get back home later this week I can check.

I wore Columbia zip off. Very light and dried quickly. I walked May18- June 28 2023. When I got into June I zipped them off and just wore them as shorts the rest of the trip. In fact they're still zipped off, I will have to zip them back on for this May-June camino. Was a little cool a couple days in May so it was nice to have them as long pants.

 

[Puck1]

I am not a fan of zip off pants. Apart from the chafing they are a pain to convert from one to the other. Far easier to have separate shorts and long pants.

I’m not a fan either. My long hiking pants have elastic in the ankles that can be pulled tighter to shorten.

 

[Enzed]

Me neither.
1) I'm not generally comfortable or feel confident in regards to the length and style of short. So it seems silly for me to buy a convertible pair of pants
2). Some styles can look a bit too "hiker" like, I'm all for lightweight breathable clothing for a camino but that doesnt mean I have to look the part of a hiker. I go on caminos to have a relaxing long walk, not to "hike".
3) I'm a bit over the fashion of cargo pockets, been there done, more than a few years ago. And I find some brands insist of including those style of pockets. I'm sure they're practical but its not a look for me.

I found a lightweight pair of jogger pants for my last/2nd camino. It's as comfy as wearing harem pants, but with a better fabric and in plain black. I often wear them in my everyday life now too.
I'll probably bring them on my next trip.

And I've also discovered the benefits of a knee length travel skirt, a good option for exploring towns in the evenings and they let your legs breath too.

But wear whatever you want to wear, fellow pilgrims. As long as you feel comfortable and confident in your clothes, you do you.

 

[Gerundino]

For my future Camino in August, I bought two similar zip trousers
This way, I can leave one pair of (long part) trousers at home.
So, at the end I have two of the same shorts where I can zip-on one pair of long trousers
Saves some space!

 

[Stephan the Painter]

OP here.
I never did buy any zip off pants. What I did end up doing was bringing one pair of regular cargo pants and one pair of short cargo pants.

On my most recent Camino I also had a lightweight pair of shorts that I wore at night around the Albergues.

But after a couple weeks I discarded the short cargo pants and just used my night shorts if I needed shorts to hike during the day. Sometimes they would be dusty at night but I lived with it for the weight savings.

But I do really like zipped cargo pockets to carry my phone and wallet to prevent loss. Despite the fashion faux pas!

 

[natcire]

I did same thing as @Gerundino with two shorts and one pant leg in the pack. I carried a refillable small 500ml bottle of water on the right side cargo pocket and a bocadillo or pack of cookies in the left side. The meseta sun bleached the short colors so they did not match the pant leg when zipped together...made it look cooler like vintage United Colors of Benetton for those who remembered those ads.

 

[Gerundino]

I did same thing as @Gerundino with two shorts and one pant leg in the pack. I carried a refillable small 500ml bottle of water on the right side cargo pocket and a bocadillo or pack of cookies in the left side. The meseta sun bleached the short colors so they did not match the pant leg when zipped together...made it look cooler like vintage United Colors of Benetton for those who remembered those ads.

Maybe this is the trick to make zip shorts fashionable! And, yes, I remember the ads!

 

[Kathy F.]

I've used Columbia zip-offs for several Caminos with no problem (I'm wearing a pair right now, in fact) except that once, when I hung them up to dry in the albergue after its daily washing, they were mistakenly taken by another pilgrim, thinking they were his! They all look alike!! I recovered my pants and since then I sew a strip of fabric on one of the pockets to make it look different.
Also, for those who worry about the terrible fashion statement zip-off shorts make, distract your judges by wearing socks with your hiking sandals. That should shut them up about your pants.

 

[natcire]

Here in the PNW, we are poor fashionistas: we started the Birkenstocks with thick wool socks. And now during warmer months, we have Crocs/ sandals with socks.

 

[Kathy F.]

Here in the PNW, we are poor fashionistas: we started the Birkenstocks with thick wool socks. And now during warmer months, we have Crocs/ sandals with socks.

 

[DwainS]

I've used Columbia zip-offs for several Caminos with no problem (I'm wearing a pair right now, in fact) except that once, when I hung them up to dry in the albergue after its daily washing, they were mistakenly taken by another pilgrim, thinking they were his! They all look alike!! I recovered my pants and since then I sew a strip of fabric on one of the pockets to make it look different.
Also, for those who worry about the terrible fashion statement zip-off shorts make, distract your judges by wearing socks with your hiking sandals. That should shut them up about your pants.

I also used Columbia zip-offs. Last year on Camino Frances and the same ones this year on my second Camino Frances. Liked having the option of wearing them as both pants and short, which I did. Also they dried quickly which is nice.

 

[David Tallan]

I also used Columbia zip-offs. Last year on Camino Frances and the same ones this year on my second Camino Frances. Liked having the option of wearing them as both pants and short, which I did. Also they dried quickly which is nice.

I have pretty exclusively worn Columbia zip-offs on every Camino subsequent to my 1989 Camino. (I don't remember what I wore on that one; probably jeans.) I hardly ever wear them as shorts, but do like the option. In 2016, the zip off at the knee really facilitated putting on and taking off my knee sleeve and later brace without removing my pants altogether. And last year, when I accidentally stepped in mud up to my knees, the zip off facilitated cleaning off the mud without removing the pants entirely. And they dry quickly.