Worth their weight in gold or 'don't bother' ?

[RobinGore]

Bladder, yes or no, I'll do a poll

 

[Pafayac]

When walking, 3 things to not forget:
- drink water
- drink water
- drink water
Personally, I cannot manage to drink enough (especially if the weather is not hot) without a bladder.

 

[CWBuff]

Yes for all the reasons @Pafayac said above and then some

 

[MikeJS]

For the same reasons as stated above. Plus, I can comfortably walk all day without eating but would not do well in the Spanish heat without drinking and a bladder ensures I stay hydrated.

 

[peterott]

I bought a backpack where I can easily grab each of the water bottles from the two outer pockets, without twisting my wrists.

Prefer this heavily over such a bladder and drink-hose

 

[J Willhaus]

Prefer water bottles.

 

[Robo]

I have used both bladders and bottles with drinking tube.
Ensuring adequate hydration is essential, and both methods allow for sufficient water to be carried.
By using a drinking tube, both methods allow for easy water access.
But which one allows for easy monitoring of consumption and water levels?

Front mounted water bottles….

For that reason alone I don’t use bladders any more.
On longer stretches, or more remote Caminos I would be forever digging into my pack to check water levels. That fear of running out, when using a bladder, caused me to carry too much water (weight).

Front mounted bottles, always in sight, allow precise monitoring, and I find encourages better hydration. I can drink to my planned consumption level freely, without worrying about how much water remains.

I loved bladders initially, but no way I would use them again.

I now remain fully hydrated, and don’t run out. (and don't end up carrying extra water)

 

[roving_rufus]

Definitely water bottles- easier to see what I have drunk and what is left. Easier to wash and clean. And easy to replace if they get damaged or are leaking.

 

[davejsy]

Bottles (obviously reusable) every time.

 

[wisepilgrim]

I started with bladders, but switched to a sturdy bottle. The bladder is easier to drink out of, which is very good. But the bottle is much easier to refill.

I also buy some of those tasty vitamin tablet tubes that you can get from the pharmacy... the effervescent kind. That way when I find a fountain that tastes a bit too metallic for my liking I can spice it up.

 

[bestfootforward]

Bottles, bottles, bottles. Easier to use, fill, clean and know how much water you have

 

[dougfitz]

I do both. Bladder for ease of drinking, weight balance, etc when walking. Small bottle as a reserve to refill the bladder if I drink all its contents, for a hydration mix at the end of each day's walk, for treating water collected from an untreated source, and to have beside my bed during the evening. I have a bladder that doesn't need to be removed from my pack to refill it, and a fitting that can be used to replace the mouthpiece so that it can be refilled from a bottle, also while still in my pack.

I recommend using a bladder, but making sure you stay hydrated is more important than how you achieve that. Do something that works for you.

 

[henrythedog]

I do both, but the other way round. 2x500ml bottles either side of my pack; easily accessible whilst walking, and 1-2l in a bladder under my pack lid as a reserve. Once I’m certain I’m within an hour or so of my end point the bladder contents get ditched.

 

[Rick of Rick and Peg]

Should I start another poll?

 

[J Willhaus]

I think it is kind of like shoes, rain ponchos vs rain coats, backpacks, and other items. It is extremely individual and a poll probably won't solve it for you.

 

[dick bird]

I think it is kind of like shoes, rain ponchos vs rain coats, backpacks, and other items. It is extremely individual and a poll probably won't solve it for you.

Absolutely. You're the one that is going to have to carry it. Go for a few long walks and try out both solutions and see which one works for you.

 

[Donna Sch]

Depends on the route and the season. If the weather is hot, have at least one bladder.
If it is cool ie under 20 degrees bottles will suffice.
I used bladders on the VDLP in June/July and they were invaluable. Bottles on the Levante/Invierno in Feb/Mar as I didn't need to drink as much and there were more opportunities to stop for a coffee or drink.
Next Camino next May/June will be tubes on 2l soft bottles plus some extra in the front pockets depending on weather. We will be doing short stages however this time around.

 

[Donna Sch]

And I need my hands for my poles and my camera. Bladders let you use your hands for other things. But bladders can leak so I bring two.

 

[Robo]

And I need my hands for my poles and my camera. Bladders let you use your hands for other things. But bladders can leak so I bring two.

Just add a tube to the bottles
They have adapters to fit most store bottles.

 

[Peterexpatkiwi]

Just add a tube to the bottles
View attachment 180344

Actually, that's exactly what I do. Half litre bottle with tube attached stashed in pack to keep everything cool, 1 l bottle in reserve used exclusively for refilling aforesaid half litre.

 

[Robo]

Actually, that's exactly what I do. Half litre bottle with tube attached stashed in pack to keep everything cool, 1 l bottle in reserve used exclusively for refilling aforesaid half litre.

I found last year, walking stages with no intermediate water points, that water management was essential.
Not wanting to carry extra weight in water, but carrying enough to be well hydrated.

Knowing my regular consumption is 10 kms / litre I could carry just the right amount and easily monitor consumption. Often reminding myself to drink more........

I never ran out. Or carried much excess.

Depending on the stage I usually carried 1.5 - 2.5 litres. a couple of days, 3 litres.
2 x 1 litre bottles on the front pack straps, always in sight with a drinking tube attached.
extra as required in my pack.
I never ran out.
And would finish most days with about 200-300 ml remaining in reserve.

I'd rather not be guessing how much water I have left.
Or find my water bladder has leaked. (It's happened)

 

[Harris]

Bottles

 

[bobojnr]

Both. Done so many of my first hikes in Crete gorges and mountains so found the bladder particularly easy to use. It was also very conveniently filled up with Metaxa for the return trip; that is before the no liquid rule for hand luggage came in.

 

[OZAJ]

I used a bladder once. The lid broke.

I use half litre bottles distributed in my pack where they remain remarkably cool. Usually 2 litres.

Some say that storing the bottles inside the pack is a problem: you have to take the pack off to access the bottles. If you have a problem with that, bearing in mind that the water is likely to still be cool ...

 

[Sweething]

Just add a tube to the bottles
They have adapters to fit most store bottles.
View attachment 180344

These are exactly what I used, (although I did use a bladder when I first started training). Best thing since sliced bread .

 

[Roland49]

Never used a bladder and never will.
To much to care about. Especially in hot areas.

I'm a "camel" and even on hot days I rarely consume 1l of water while walking.
I fill up on the evening after I done all the necessary procedures of a long walk.
My "go-to" system are 2 half-litre single-use bottles. Sturdy, lightweight and cheap.

 

[ShellToucher]

Bladder, yes or no, I'll do a poll

View attachment 180327

 

[ShellToucher]

Here is another hydration system that personally, I believe works better:

 

[Jeff Crawley]

When walking, 3 things to not forget:
- drink water
- drink water
- drink water
Personally, I cannot manage to drink enough (especially if the weather is not hot) without a bladder.

Not forgetting to empty bladder . . .

 

[Sd217]

bottles for all the reasons as above

 

[Pilgrim Patricia]

Re-fillable bottles (one litre or smaller)! Given the opportunity I'll freeze one or two overnight so they can keep others cool.

 

[dbeatriceb]

Bladder, yes or no, I'll do a poll

View attachment 180327

I’ve used both and definitely prefer bottles over bladder.
Bladders offer a certain amount of convenience but, for me, cleanliness is an issue. That is where I find a bladder inconvenient.
Also, carrying a water bottle on the front attached to the backpack strap plus carrying an extra bottle in a side pocket distributes weight differently and takes just a little bit of the load off my back.

 

[OSUbuckeye85]

I have used both bladders and bottles with drinking tube.
Ensuring adequate hydration is essential, and both methods allow for sufficient water to be carried.
By using a drinking tube, both methods allow for easy water access.
But which one allows for easy monitoring of consumption and water levels?

Front mounted water bottles….

For that reason alone I don’t use bladders any more.
On longer stretches, or more remote Caminos I would be forever digging into my pack to check water levels. That fear of running out, when using a bladder, caused me to carry too much water (weight).

Front mounted bottles, always in sight, allow precise monitoring, and I find encourages better hydration. I can drink to my planned consumption level freely, without worrying about how much water remains.

I loved bladders initially, but no way I would use them again.

I now remain fully hydrated, and don’t run out. (and don't end up carrying extra water)

What front-mounted water bottle do you use?

 

[JFG]

Bladder, yes or no, I'll do a poll

View attachment 180327

Definite yes. I used this one from Amazon after using the more popular brands and it worked great, it was sturdy, easy to clean and inexpensive. Not the greatest color though.

Hydration Bladder, 1.5L-2L-3L Water Bladder for Hiking Backpack Leak Proof Water Reservoir Storage Bag, BPA-Free Water Pouch Hydration Pack for Camping Cycling Running, Military Green 1.5-2-3 Liter​

 

[EWhite]

Learn More — One Bottle Hydration™

The One Bottle Hydration System adds a convenient CamelBak style drinking tube to your wide mouth Nalgene or Hydro Flask. Put One Bottle into your pack instead of a hydration bladder and enjoy convenience plus versatility!

www.one-bottle.com

 

[El Cascayal]

Bladder, yes or no, I'll do a poll

View attachment 180327

I find this kind of bladder system very difficult to use: unscrewing cap, water leaks out, need to get it out of backpack in order to fill…
I vote for this ingenious solution by Osprey (this is newest version): seals water tight, no spills, very easy to open, fill, and close. Once you get the hang of it, can fill it without getting it out of backpack but I prefer to pop it out and fill it from a faucet. Green arrow easy clip closing. Red circle easy to disconnect push button tubing.

 

[pkonopka]

Bladder, yes or no, I'll do a poll

View attachment 180327

Yes, get and use. Water bottles are fine but very inconvenient to use while walking. A good bladder (easy to fill, durable but light) is worth it.