I’m pretty sure that at some point(s) many, if not most, pilgrims question what they are doing and consider the possibility of quitting. And I’m quite sure that I’ll experience that feeling when I do my first CF this spring. But I wonder where/when this tends to happen to most pilgrims? Is there a section or point where the questioning tends to set in?
(addendum: please don’t reply that it depends on the person. I’d like to know your experience. Thanks.)
I think that if people quit, they're most likely to do it in those first few days, but I'm not sure what stats I saw that make me think that. I completed about 220 miles (the amount I planned) over 20 years ago. I was living in Spain at the time and just got curious about what it would be like to do it, and that was what I had time to do. It was an absolutely transformative experience. I was there doing research for my Ph.D., and I said then that if I finished the dissertation and got a job, I wanted to return and do it again, but a longer distance. And lo, that's what happened, so I couldn't wait to hit the Camino again.
I started in SJPP that second time, which hardly anyone did back then. There was no Orisson, no water up there, no km markers, no nothing (and this was before smart phones), and not another soul all day. It was gorgeous, but very stressful because I was seriously worried about running out of water, and I didn't know how far I had to keep going. I got to Roncesvalles and there was this HUUUUGE albergue, a new construction that hadn't been there before. I didn't sleep well, and there were very gruff hospitaleros kicking us out at some crazy hour of the morning. In the next place, I realized that I was completely exhausted and just not into this and maybe should just go do something else. There was a young German guy who was very proud of himself because, he said, when HE started something, HE liked to finish it.
The thing is that I just HAD finished quite a monumental thing. I'd been pushing myself for months and months to get the dissertation done, and I left for Spain about two days after my defense. I should have given it more time. What I really needed was to sit on a beach somewhere and stare off into space and most definitely NOT push myself and set a fresh goal every day. I needed to just be lazy.
I ended up pausing in Pamplona to assess whether or not to continue. I think I spent 3 days there and just didn't want to keep going. (I DID, however, really enjoy the religious art museum there and just wandering around.) So I called my friend in Madrid and asked her if I could come and sleep on her floor until I figured out what to do. (She had just bought an apartment and hadn't moved in yet; there was no furniture there. I bought a camping mat.) I ended up deciding that what I really wanted was just to be home and sleeping in and relaxing and getting ready for my move to start my new job. So I changed my ticket and went home. It was the right decision, but I think if I'd given myself more time after my defense before leaving for Spain, I would have been fine. But I have no regrets about having gone home back then. I just had no energy -- mentally, physically, emotionally, I was too fried.
That was over two decades ago. I am now at some crossroads and feel a need to ponder things, so I'm going back soon. Like last time, I happen to have recently finished another major writing project, but this time I gave myself some more time between than and starting the Camino. My goal is to have no expectations and just be open to whatever comes and see what the Camino wants to say now. I think this is going to be very different than the last time, the aborted time, because of that time gap I allowed this time around after finishing up a major project. I'm able to just take my time somewhat if I want, so I won't have to push hard every day. But if I find that I'm just really not into this the way I think I will be, or it's just too crowded for me, or I get injured, or whatever, I will do something else instead. I won't abandon it at the first sign of discomfort or anything, but if it's just not working and that's not a temporary feeling, I have some back-up plans in mind, places in Spain where there's a lot of natural beauty and not too many tourists, or at least not many foreign ones. If I need to leave the Camino behind and enjoy other areas of Spain, that'll be OK, too. And I feel like being open to that possibility is actually part of the openness to the experience in general. I am planning on spending some additional time in Spain after the Camino anyway, so if I get to that "other stuff" earlier, well, that'll be fine, too.
Some people learn from the Camino how not to give up, how to persist. People who've already persisted a lot and not given up might need to learn different things, like how to know when you need to stop.