- Time of past OR future Camino
- French
Any suggestions on the best App or Website to check the weather on the Camino Frances please.
Remove ads on the forum by becoming a donating member. More here. |
---|
I use Weather app (France) before I go and then simply local paper once there. I specifically target saint Jean. Weather diagrams and symbols are pretty universal. I also use Weather app Spain for Roncesvalles onwards.Any suggestions on the best App or Website to check the weather on the Camino Frances please.
I make use of aemet.es, meteoblue.com and windy.com, all available online and as an app. Aemet because of their detailed alerts (if and when there are any), Meteoblue because of their Meteogram and Rainspot features, Windy for the nice interactive graphics and general overviews. In Galicia, I've made use of the MeteoGalicia app.Any suggestions on the best App or Website to check the weather on the Camino Frances please.
14 Day Weather Saint-Jean-Pied-de-Port - meteoblue
The professional 14-day weather trend for Saint-Jean-Pied-de-Port. Showing the uncertainty and reliability of the weather forecast.www.meteoblue.com
I know weather is temperamental but still. Nice forecast for SJPP over the next two weeks.
Meteoblue knows where Ibañeta is . (Puerto de Ibañeta is the name of the pass of the Valcarlos route.)This is awesome! Thank you. I’m not going route Napoleon this time. Is checking Valcarlos and Roncesvalles a good indicator or is there a location with a better indicator of the worst weather possible, for that route?
This anecdote is just further proof of my theory that the locals don’t know more about the local weather than the weather forecast does and usually less.He paused for a moment, bowed his head a little, looked towards the window and replied: "Something like that”.
I imagine the local guy in that story was politely trying his best not to laugh out loud at the question. For current conditions, our own eyes are the most accurate instruments. Who needs an app for that? It's silly.my theory that the locals don’t know more about the local weather than the weather forecast does and usually less
the"lookoutofthewindow" or "youcantchangeitanyway" app or the "justtakeithowitcomes.go"Any suggestions on the best App or Website to check the weather on the Camino Frances please.
Any suggestions on the best App or Website to check the weather on the Camino Frances please.
I was at dinner in the Albergue O Abrigadoiro at San Xulian do Camino in 2010 when a group of pilgrims took themselves off to watch the weather forecast on the news. When I asked about their interest, they responded by asking me how I knew what the weather would be like in the morning if I didn't watch the news. My response was something like: I put my head out the door when I am getting ready to leave. If its cold, I put my fleece on, if its wet as well, I wear my rain-jacket. After all, there is no option but to walk.The fascination with knowing the weather forecast is one thing but the reality is you need to keep moving another 20km each day or you aren't going to go anywhere.
Agree, can’t beat sticking your head out the windowLookoutthewindow.com
But if you must use an app, Windy is superb.
Much as I prefer it for immediate conditions, what Lookoutthewindow.com can't give you is a forecast for what will happen in 3 or 4 hours time when you are (say) crossing that exposed mountain.can’t beat sticking your head out the window
That would only have worked for me for my first and last days on the Norte. Every other day it started out foggy or cloudy and a bit chilly and the skies cleared and the sun came out by 10 or 11. Layers!Leave the Albergue early in the morning. Look at the sky and maybe you can guess what the weather is going to be like.
Buen Camino, and enjoy our " Buen Tiempo"
I’m curious to know what the weather is like at altitude in the Pyrenees as well. Does anyone know?I make use of aemet.es, meteoblue.com and windy.com, all available online and as an app. Aemet because of their detailed alerts (if and when there are any), Meteoblue because of their Meteogram and Rainspot features, Windy for the nice interactive graphics and general overviews. In Galicia, I've made use of the MeteoGalicia app.
My benchmark for crossing the Pyrenees: Does the weather app know where the Ibañeta and Bentarte passes are and what the weather conditions will be like at altitude when I would be there?
Generally, for a given month, up to a point, maybe. For today, look out of the window then be prepared to look again later in the day. Put on or take off clothing as appropriate. Watch television news and weather. Ask locals. For tomorrow, there will be a forecast somewhere. Take it with a large pinch of salt.I’m curious to know what the weather is like at altitude in the Pyrenees as well. Does anyone know?
Yes. There are links with this information in this thread which you will see when you read further than post #3 to which you replied.I’m curious to know what the weather is like at altitude in the Pyrenees as well. Does anyone know?
Going up in altitude generally gets cooler, coming down generally gets a bit warmer.I’m curious to know what the weather is like at altitude in the Pyrenees as well. Does anyone know?
You can use the Meteoblue weather app and search for the location: Col de BentarteThis is awesome! Thank you. I’m not going route Napoleon this time. Is checking Valcarlos and Roncesvalles a good indicator or is there a location with a better indicator of the worst weather possible, for that route?
Meteoblue and Windy for sure . And I also add the Meteogram app. It is all about having a good selection of weather information providers that deal well with fast changing altitude weather conditions.I make use of aemet.es, meteoblue.com and windy.com, all available online and as an app. Aemet because of their detailed alerts (if and when there are any), Meteoblue because of their Meteogram and Rainspot features, Windy for the nice interactive graphics and general overviews. In Galicia, I've made use of the MeteoGalicia app.
My benchmark for crossing the Pyrenees: Does the weather app know where the Ibañeta and Bentarte passes are and what the weather conditions will be like at altitude when I would be there?
This comment makes funny reading this morning, given the numerous weather reports, weather forecasts and severe weather warnings that have popped up on the forum over the last 36 hours or so , due to the current Continent wide cold snap. I still fail to understand what could be wrong with knowing what the weather is likely to be. It’s not much different to me from knowing how far away the next towns are, what they are called and how long it is likely for me to get there.That's all very interesting but what are you actually going to do if it rains? Because there isn't much you can do other than one foot in front of the other and decent rain gear . So you need to stop thinking about the forecast and go for a walk. If the weather is impossible then you will probably notice anyway.
Just a little episode...That's all very interesting but what are you actually going to do if it rains? Because there isn't much you can do other than one foot in front of the other and decent rain gear . So you need to stop thinking about the forecast and go for a walk. If the weather is impossible then you will probably notice anyway.
There's probably nothing wrong with that, but in the past, I have considered it unnecessary. However, thinking about the circumstances where I have seen people fixated on getting the forecast, I would admit there might be value for some people in having an accurate forecast.I still fail to understand what could be wrong with knowing what the weather is likely to be. It’s not much different to me from knowing how far away the next towns are, what they are called and how long it is likely for me to get there.
a group of pilgrims being unprepared with correct clothing with the inference they could have avoided this by regular checking a weather app. I think the sentiment is laudable, but the example isn't. My view is that if the group didn't have the correct clothing and gear in their packs, no amount of checking a weather app would have made one bit of difference here.Three weeks later a group of 20 something Irish pilgrims had to be rescued near Izandorre refuge on Napoleon route, because they were ill prepared in terms of correct clothing gear.
Making a routine of checking daily a simple weather app might make the difference in avoiding life threatening situations. Never, NEVER underestimate the weather conditions on mountain ranges.
I would go further, and suggest that any group that hasn't prepared for either the climate, or the specific alpine conditions, would not get much benefit from a weather app letting them know that they are walking into weather conditions they aren't going to be able to cope with.
That is for the most part, true. However, I was just seeing on several of my Camino Facebook groups yesterday or today alerts for pilgrims in several locations on the Camino Frances and Aragones to hole up for a day or two and stop walking because of dangerous weather (I expect snow, in this case). So presumably there are times it is best not not just put one foot in front of the other and they are not sure that pilgrims will be aware of that when looking out the albergue door.That's all very interesting but what are you actually going to do if it rains? Because there isn't much you can do other than one foot in front of the other and decent rain gear . So you need to stop thinking about the forecast and go for a walk. If the weather is impossible then you will probably notice anyway.
I walked the Primitivo last April and Apps weren't the most useful....But do you what was? Asking the locals. I was in Bodenaya and not only did the hospitalero tell me a storm was coming so did every shop owner I talked to...and sure enough the snow came when they said it would.Any suggestions on the best App or Website to check the weather on the Camino Frances please.
It seems to me that you are condoning people going into the Pyrenees unprepared for the alpine conditions that they face in any season, summer, winter or otherwise. More, you suggest that it is unreasonable to make such preparations on the basis, it would appear, that they need to be prepared for a winter mountaineering expedition. Nothing could be further from the truth.Well, sorry but I totally disagree with you.
They were at mid August, hence mid summer. They got into trouble because they didn't had, consciously or unconsciously, the updated weather information on high Napoleon Route which indicated that there were snowstorm conditions for the next day.
They got into trouble because they simply didn't had the adequate gear for those very particular conditions and some of them went into hypothermia.
Nobody carries the specific type of clothing and layers, gloves and mountain boots, etc to go through that route in mid summer, because it's simply logistically wrong since they wouldn't be used elsewhere.
But If they've known about those conditions beforehand they could either postpone their walk or go through Valcarlos.
Having more information is always better than having less or no information at all. What each one decides subsequently to do with that information that really depends on their judgment.
Oh, that reminds me, and I think that it has not yet been mentioned among the weather apps in this thread: the Pilgrim Office in SJPP uses Viewweather for their weather forecast. I think that they used Meteoblue when I visited their office for the first time many years ago and that’s how I discovered Meteoblue initially. I remember that they had a daily printout on a notice board. I have never asked the locals of SJPP what they use as their source but I guess it’s mostly the TV weather forecast.advice from the SJPP Pilgrim Office
Well it seems to me that you have some trouble in understating what I write since what you understand is the opposite of my words.It seems to me that you are condoning people going into the Pyrenees unprepared for the alpine conditions that they face in any season, summer, winter or otherwise. More, you suggest that it is unreasonable to make such preparations on the basis, it would appear, that they need to be prepared for a winter mountaineering expedition. Nothing could be further from the truth.
They didn't, as you suggest here and in your earlier retelling of their story at post #40, get into trouble because they didn't have good weather information. They had excellent weather information. They didn't need a forecast, they were walking in it and it would appear didn't have appropriate clothing, and then appear to have responded inappropriately by continuing to push on when conditions became dangerous.
More, they didn't get hypothermia because they didn't have the right gear, although that would have contributed to their plight once they had made what appears to me to have been a bad decision, that was to continue walking. At any time up to that point, I suggest that they would have had the choice to return to SJPP, a decision that they failed to make.
What clothing and equipment they did have hasn't been made clear, but I have walked in summer alpine conditions are roughly similar altitudes here in Australia, and one doesn't need anything like winter gloves and mountain boots. What I find is sufficient is to have the right layers, including competent wind and rain protection. You also need to be willing to recognise when conditions have deteriorated to the point where, even with all the layers you have, it isn't safe to continue walking. At which point it is time to either find shelter or get off the mountain.
Would having good weather information the night before have made any difference? That is hard to tell, but let me suggest that it wouldn't. Clearly the group didn't make good decisions when they were actually in this weather. I wonder what makes you think they would have made a decision not to walk if they were discussing this in the comfort of their accommodation in SJPP that morning or on the previous evening. They would have had to imagine what it would have been like, a poor substitute for actually experiencing it. If they couldn't make a good decision when they were actually experiencing these weather conditions, I think it is fanciful for anyone to believe a better decision would have been made merely based on the forecast.
How unfortunate, @RuiCarneiro, that you appear to have misunderstood the meaning of the word 'condone' which I used in my earlier post, to mean 'condemn'. These two words have almost completely opposite meanings. I don't think it very useful to respond to that element of this post without giving you the opportunity to look back on my post and your comments in that light, and work out whether you want to edit your remarks.Well it seems to me that you have some trouble in understating what I write since what you understand is the opposite of my words.
I never said I condemned them for not having the right gear for "mountain expedition". I said exactly the contrary. Nobody, including me, carries the gear for "winter mountain expeditions" in mid summer, on that location. And I know from personal experience how fast and dramatic weather can shift in mountain ranges.
But we clearly have one difference. You like to make decisions exclusively on the fly. And although taking the right decisions at the right moment accordingly to present conditions is essential, I NEVER fail to get all the necessary information beforehand for my safety, including weather reports. Years of experience in mountains and in all conditions taught me that.
Ps: i don't know your experience in mountains specially on extreme cold days, but adequate mountain boots and gloves are of absolute primary importance. Frostbites on toes and fingers are on the top of bad consequences for inadequate choice of gear.
it is unfortunate that you have reached this conclusion. On the matter of deciding what clothing and equipment to bring to the camino, I have for many years suggested that members observe an old adage of 'packing for the climate, dressing for the weather'. This is a far longer term planning paradigm than what appears to be your planning horizon of a few days weather forecasts. I am tempted to ask what real decisions you have actually made based on that. Did you go and find different gear somewhere because you didn't have some item of clothing like a good rain jacket in the face of a forecast of a few days of rain? Or perhaps stock up on sunscreen because there was going to be a string of high UV days, and you didn't have long trousers or long sleeved shirts to protect your skin?You like to make decisions exclusively on the fly.
noting her later clarification:That's all very interesting but what are you actually going to do if it rains? Because there isn't much you can do other than one foot in front of the other and decent rain gear . So you need to stop thinking about the forecast and go for a walk. If the weather is impossible then you will probably notice anyway.
but I will gently suggest that apart from mountain walking ( or walking up a big hill) you can just keep going, even if you have shorter days. Also that asking at the albergue, newspaper or TV forecast, or even looking out of the window will give all the information needed.
Any suggestions on the best App or Website to check the weather on the Camino Frances please.
Did you ask the locals how they knew?I walked the Primitivo last April and Apps weren't the most useful....But do you what was? Asking the locals. I was in Bodenaya and not only did the hospitalero tell me a storm was coming so did every shop owner I talked to...and sure enough the snow came when they said it would.
I use Windy. It's a great App!Any suggestions on the best App or Website to check the weather on the Camino Frances please.