I have only done the entire Norte so I cannot compare and when I hit the split with the Primitivo it was already November of 2018. After the split you still have some great days on or near the coast. The only place I was not crazy about was Gijon and spent the night there. The walk in isn't so great but that is about it. It was super quiet and there were many nights I was either alone or with just a few pilgrims but remember it was November and it seemed like every other pilgrim I met before the split was taking the Primitivo. I enjoyed the solitude. About Baamonde it gradually got a little more crowded in the albergues but during the day there was still solitude but if there were some pilgrims. If you choose to do the Norte I would recommend you staying here:
Información del albergue de peregrinos Albergue O Xistral, en As Paredes (Castromaior): Precio, plazas, características, etc...
www.gronze.com
This albergue is in the middle of the woods and is about 6K past Abadin. It just appears out of nowhere but you can't miss it. The couple that own this beautiful albergue could not have been nicer. There were just three of us in a beautiful and super clean house. There is a large yard and I t a swimming pool.
There is a small selection of food to buy. We all chose the dinner that they prepared and it was wonderful with really good conversation. The house and the beds are so comfortable. It rained almost the entire night and was raining hard when I woke up for breakfast. I still left and before I was out of the yard it went from pouring rain to only hearing the dripping of water off of trees.
The second recommendation is this one:
Información del albergue de peregrinos Albergue de peregrinos del Monasterio de Sobrado dos Monxes, en Sobrado dos Monxes: Precio, plazas, características, etc...
www.gronze.com
It is a beautiful monastery with an albergue. I intended to stay here but two days earlier I slept in Baamonde in another stone public albergue and it was so cold we could see our breath. I slept in EVERYTHING I had as I only brought a silk sleep sack. Not too smart huh??? A friend stayed here and said it was a good experience and he enjoyed it a great deal. But he said without a sleeping bag I made the right choice. Gronze shows it was remodeled in 2021. I walked the grounds and saw everything and it seems really like a place to stay on camino.
I ended up staying here:
Información del albergue de peregrinos Albergue Lecer, en Sobrado dos Monxes: Precio, plazas, características, etc...
www.gronze.com
It was an excellent and clean albergue. Very typical of the newer albergues you find all over the different caminos. I would stay there again. It is a good choice if the monastery is full or you would rather not stay there.
The Norte was always quiet and peaceful. It was not until I got to Arzua and rejoined the CF that the crowds, even for November descended on me. I am sure nothing like in August or September. The great thing was that more than made up for the crowds were 5 friends I met on the Norte that took the Primitivo were sitting in a great little Pizza Restaurant. I also stayed in a wonderful albergue in Arzua the last time year in late November.
Información del albergue de peregrinos Albergue San Francisco, en Arzúa: Precio, plazas, características, etc...
www.gronze.com
Not a comparison but only my experience.
I do not think you will be disappointed staying on the Norte.