long trails
Active Member
- Time of past OR future Camino
- Frances 2012
Remove ads on the forum by becoming a donating member. More here. |
---|
there is a big difference between a post Camino low feeling (...) and the more clinical and serious Endogenous depression.
I was looking for a recent topic on post-trail depression so I could add a link to an excellent article that was shared on hiking forum, but I could n't find one, so here you go!
I use to find that even after a four or five day hike I'd feel quite down, for no apparent reason. Since then I have realised the depth of the 'depression' seems to correlate with the length of the hike.
Anyway, the link is below, hope it's ok to share it. I learned quite a bit from what was written and post-trail depression seems to entirely make sense now.
https://just2hikers.wordpress.com/2015/01/14/post-trail-depression/
The writer refers to the longer U.S. thru-hikes, but I think a lot of it is relevant to the Caminos too.
"Post Camino depression"? No offense, but can't say I ever felt depressed after being on vacation.
I'm always just grateful that I'm blessed enough to be able to go on a long vacation, while so many others out there are never able to.
Yeah, no doubt returning to a job that one is unhappy with would play a role in not wanting the experience of the Camino, or any similar activity to end.I wonder how many people who feel depressed on returning have jobs they like? After a backpacking trip I always feel happy when I get back, but I have a family I'm happy to see and a job I'm happy to return to. When I went on my first long overseas trip in my mid-20's, I felt pretty down when I returned. But I was marginally employed and broke af then too!
You're description isn't based on real scientific conclusions. So....me as an op, I'm slightly offended. One persons life event can easily be, just a back ground news story!!I do not want to diminish anyone's feelings regarding post Camino emotions. This is in no way a personal comment to the OP or towards the article.
Just mentioning that there is a big difference between a post Camino low feeling due to less endorphines aka Exogenous depression ( or life events ) and the more clinical and serious Endogenous depression. IMHO.
That's what I do!I can relate. Upon my return home last year I felt down for two weeks, listless and jaded. First I blamed it on the fact that the adventure was over, some sort of psychological backlash. But then it hit me: a lot less endorphins because I just couldn't get off the couch. I was kicking the habit, and cold turkey at that.
Amazing really, that a camino can actually develop into a physical addiction. So yeah, like simeon I am planning the next one...
I understood that to be intended as a simple reminder that there is a difference between "normal" ups and downs, and clinical depression. Sometimes people who are experiencing the ups-and-downs can benefit from this reminder, and put things into perspective. Those who suffer depression can also be reminded that different treatment might be needed. I don't speak as any kind of expert on the topic.You're description isn't based on real scientific conclusions. So....me as an op, I'm slightly offended. One persons life event can easily be, just a back ground news story!!
That Black Dog, always at my heels, has nothing to do with Camino past or present. It sat there, quiet in the corner, the day I was born and it will sniff at and widdle on every path I take. I keep it behind me with activity, and service and offerings to the Gods. And sometimes I let it sneak a little closer with to much reliance on the bottle or the gear. Sometimes I call it in and hold it close; its my oldest friend.
Post camino blues will cloud the rational of many and especially those who get a little taste of freedom on their 6 week walk back to the airport. The dog can't be bought off with a few biccies or a juicy bone and it won't matter how far you walk on how many trails that cold wet nose will always be close to your heels.
@SabineP has a handle on the issue; a leash on the beast. There is a difference between the blues and the black.
And on that cheerful note its obviously time to plan my next camino...
Wow, what a deep and allegorical way you expressed yourself here. I'm blown away by your candor on such a sensitive subject. I appreciate your insight based on your own personal experience.That Black Dog, always at my heels, has nothing to do with Camino past or present. It sat there, quiet in the corner, the day I was born and it will sniff at and widdle on every path I take. I keep it behind me with activity, and service and offerings to the Gods. And sometimes I let it sneak a little closer with to much reliance on the bottle or the gear. Sometimes I call it in and hold it close; its my oldest friend.
Post camino blues will cloud the rational of many and especially those who get a little taste of freedom on their 6 week walk back to the airport. The dog can't be bought off with a few biccies or a juicy bone and it won't matter how far you walk on how many trails that cold wet nose will always be close to your heels.
@SabineP has a handle on the issue; a leash on the beast. There is a difference between the blues and the black.
And on that cheerful note its obviously time to plan my next camino...
I understood that to be intended as a simple reminder that there is a difference between "normal" ups and downs, and clinical depression. Sometimes people who are experiencing the ups-and-downs can benefit from this reminder, and put things into perspective. Those who suffer depression can also be reminded that different treatment might be needed. I don't speak as any kind of expert on the topic.
... it might just be the realization that the life you have is not the life you want. And in that case it might just be time for a radical life change ... SY
I like this![Warning: Late night navel gazing ahead]
@SYates, I've been tinkering with a related thought lately. Maybe more subtle than radical change. From my journal...
"It is possible that, in its simplest form, the Camino is a temporary life support system. It can serve as an alternative mental and physical infrastructure while the pilgrim systematically dismantles, inspects, and maintains their real world life. The Camino provides essential services such as access to food, water, shelter, social and spiritual support, all for a reasonable cost.
By most accounts, life on the Camino is a simple routine of waking, walking, observing, eating/drinking, and sleeping. Other than a few primitive measures for hygiene and personal care, there are not a lot of responsibilities to burden the mind of the walker. Such a routine can free up significant mental and emotional resources. Resources which one could, consciously or subconsciously, put to bear on the crusty, complicated mental apparatus accreted, like barnacles, over the course of a lifetime. Such a subjective, unbiased yet ruthlessly judgmental review could provide surprising insights into what is right and what could be improved or discarded altogether with little or no negative impact on one's future prospects.
Yet, it is unrealistic to think that a pilgrim can easily jettison any significant part of this mental apparatus, for the Camino is unlikely to provide suitable long term replacements for existing relationships, jobs, life philosophies etc. In the most likely scenarios, one may gain a revised perspective, perhaps a re-prioritization or a strategy for a midlife correction.
Or they may just lose 20 lbs and take a lot of pictures to show the folks back home and that may be sufficient, in and of itself."
Not sure where I'm going with this but it seemed relevant.
Todo está Buen.
-jgp
You are a deep thinking fellow and I loved reading and pondering this excerpt from your journal. A very well written and thought provoking piece. Thanks for sharing it![Warning: Late night navel gazing ahead]
@SYates, I've been tinkering with a related thought lately. Maybe more subtle than radical change. From my journal...
"It is possible that, in its simplest form, the Camino is a temporary life support system. It can serve as an alternative mental and physical infrastructure while the pilgrim systematically dismantles, inspects, and maintains their real world life. The Camino provides essential services such as access to food, water, shelter, social and spiritual support, all for a reasonable cost.
By most accounts, life on the Camino is a simple routine of waking, walking, observing, eating/drinking, and sleeping. Other than a few primitive measures for hygiene and personal care, there are not a lot of responsibilities to burden the mind of the walker. Such a routine can free up significant mental and emotional resources. Resources which one could, consciously or subconsciously, put to bear on the crusty, complicated mental apparatus accreted, like barnacles, over the course of a lifetime. Such a subjective, unbiased yet ruthlessly judgmental review could provide surprising insights into what is right and what could be improved or discarded altogether with little or no negative impact on one's future prospects.
Yet, it is unrealistic to think that a pilgrim can easily jettison any significant part of this mental apparatus, for the Camino is unlikely to provide suitable long term replacements for existing relationships, jobs, life philosophies etc. In the most likely scenarios, one may gain a revised perspective, perhaps a re-prioritization or a strategy for a midlife correction.
Or they may just lose 20 lbs and take a lot of pictures to show the folks back home and that may be sufficient, in and of itself."
Not sure where I'm going with this but it seemed relevant.
Todo está Buen.
-jgp
I was looking for a recent topic on post-trail depression so I could add a link to an excellent article that was shared on hiking forum, but I could n't find one, so here you go!
I use to find that even after a four or five day hike I'd feel quite down, for no apparent reason. Since then I have realised the depth of the 'depression' seems to correlate with the length of the hike.
Anyway, the link is below, hope it's ok to share it. I learned quite a bit from what was written and post-trail depression seems to entirely make sense now.
https://just2hikers.wordpress.com/2015/01/14/post-trail-depression/
The writer refers to the longer U.S. thru-hikes, but I think a lot of it is relevant to the Caminos too.
I'm not sure that this is true. The fact that you are comparing your experience to what you perceive is the experience of most other pilgrims can also contribute to a negative mood.It shouldn't be like this and for most Pilgrims I am sure its a time of great euphoria.
Absolutely! I spent a few days in Madrid after my Camino, and wanted to follow a few people wearing backpacks at the train station who looked like they were about to begin the Camino.sorry to drag you all up out of your deep thoughts but has anyone experienced waking a few days after finishing with a huge urge to walk nearly to the point of it being a physical sensation?
Thanks for the kind words. It was the vino tinto talking though I think. -jgpYou are a deep thinking fellow and I loved reading and pondering this excerpt from your journal. A very well written and thought provoking piece. Thanks for sharing it!
I was looking for a recent topic on post-trail depression so I could add a link to an excellent article that was shared on hiking forum, but I could n't find one, so here you go!
I use to find that even after a four or five day hike I'd feel quite down, for no apparent reason. Since then I have realised the depth of the 'depression' seems to correlate with the length of the hike.
Anyway, the link is below, hope it's ok to share it. I learned quite a bit from what was written and post-trail depression seems to entirely make sense now.
https://just2hikers.wordpress.com/2015/01/14/post-trail-depression/
The writer refers to the longer U.S. thru-hikes, but I think a lot of it is relevant to the Caminos too.
I was looking for a recent topic on post-trail depression so I could add a link to an excellent article that was shared on hiking forum, but I could n't find one, so here you go!
I use to find that even after a four or five day hike I'd feel quite down, for no apparent reason. Since then I have realised the depth of the 'depression' seems to correlate with the length of the hike.
Anyway, the link is below, hope it's ok to share it. I learned quite a bit from what was written and post-trail depression seems to entirely make sense now.
https://just2hikers.wordpress.com/2015/01/14/post-trail-depression/
The writer refers to the longer U.S. thru-hikes, but I think a lot of it is relevant to the Caminos too.
You are onto something very true, very powerful. Problem is, would I prefer to be a permanent pilgrim rather than what I am now? Maybe yes, at least for some time. Until I have done all Caminos one after the other. A couple of years? When I go back home would I still have a family? Those are questions that keep me up at night, especially since I turn 60 this year and could presumably make a "radical change", as you so aptly put it.Endorphins certainly play a part, but if you feel really depressed after returning home it might just be the realization that the life you have is not the life you want. And in that case it might just be time for a radical life change ...
Buen Camino de la vida, SY
Well it sounds like a wonderful daydream to take this Camino wanderlust to a new level, but as much as I've enjoyed the freedom and simplicity of 6 weeks in Spain on pilgrimages, it always feels good to know I have family back home who love me, waiting for my return. I think if we were permanent pilgrims much of what we look forward to...the excitement, anticipation, and planning would dissappear. The new routine of "constant Camino" would most likely soon become "old news" to us and lose appeal. Think hard before you make big changes in your life. Just my thoughts.You are onto something very true, very powerful. Problem is, would I prefer to be a permanent pilgrim rather than what I am now? Maybe yes, at least for some time. Until I have done all Caminos one after the other. A couple of years? When I go back home would I still have a family? Those are questions that keep me up at night, especially since I turn 60 this year and could presumably make a "radical change", as you so aptly put it.
Hi
Similar to others I have also come to the ( unscientific ) conclusion that it is this departure from living in the present that causes the drop in mood .
The best cure is to jump back on the horse !
Like many others I felt down and a little at a loss after my camino. My scientifically unproven theory about why this happens goes like this....buried somewhere deep in our genetic code, obscured by modern life, lies the hunter-gatherer DNA pattern from which we are supposedly descended. This pattern thrives on the concept of daily physical activity to meet our basic needs. So what do we do each day on the camino? Engage in physical activity as we "hunt" and "gather" a place to sleep, our meals, etc. Sitting at a desk all day or driving around in cars like a lot of us do in everyday life is probably not consistent with our genetic hardwiring. Not to mention the relative simplicity of the Camino lifestyle. Not really any other requirements than to safely make it from point A to point B, find a place to stay and something to eat. And because we're on the Camino nothing more is expected of us by the outside world.
Why do wandering people conceive the world as perfect whereas sedentary ones always try to change it?
Thank you sooo much. I've been going thru this and had no idea why I was feeling so empty and like a loved one has died. Thank you again.I was looking for a recent topic on post-trail depression so I could add a link to an excellent article that was shared on a hiking forum, but I could n't find one, so here you go!
I find that even after a four or five day hike I could feel quite down, for no apparent external reason. Since then I have realised the depth of the 'depression' seems to correlate with the length of the hike.
Anyway, the link is below, hope it's ok to share it. I learned quite a bit from what was written and post-trail depression seems to entirely make sense now.
https://just2hikers.wordpress.com/2015/01/14/post-trail-depression/
The writer refers to the longer U.S. thru-hikes, but I think a lot of it is relevant to the Caminos too.
Thanks for reviving this old thread, I hadn't seen it. Interesting article quoted by the OP.Thank you sooo much. I've been going thru this and had no idea why I was feeling so empty and like a loved one has died. Thank you again.
Camino Blues....
When I Finished my first long Camino I wrote what I left you here today.
Hope you find it means something for you all, my Camino brothers.
Excuse my english and accept my feelings
"Yesterday I finished El Camino de Santiago.
Today is a day of rest and return.
Today I can get up at any time I want and enjoy Santiago to my liking.
But customs are customs and I wake up at seven.
Of course, today I have a long breakfast and after preparing my backpack for the plane for the last time, I go to Santiago to do some sightseeing.
When stepping on the streets, pilgrims are already arriving at the Plaza del Obradoiro. I look at them with the until now habitual face of camaraderie and complicity, I even greet them with the usual until yesterday "Buen Camino!... but it's not the same anymore.
Today I am no longer an active pilgrim (I stress the word "active", because once a pilgrim you are a pilgrim all your life). Now I am no more than an ordinary tourist; although worse dressed than average.
For the first time since yesterday I am aware that my pilgrimage is over. And it hurts me.
It has been just over three intense and wonderful weeks. Absolutely different from what I am used to, demanding, hard and at the same time revitalizing and full.
I have shared sweat, steps and efforts with people from places as different as Korea, France, Switzerland, Italy, Germany, Alaska or South Africa. Even some occasional Spanish!
I have learned that if your task for the day is to walk 20 or 30 kilometers, then you walk them and that's all.
I have discovered how good a bit of York ham and some walnuts taste in the shade of a tree when you are tired.
I've learned to endure and even enjoy the rain on your face and the mud that won't let you lift your feet.
I have seen my shadow, companion on the way, always walking ahead of me, from East to West, marking the route.
I have experienced that the best thing against foot pain is to keep walking. They don't hurt less, but you even get used to the pain.
I have suffered the agony of the steep slopes, knowing that sooner or later I will reach the top and then everything will be easier. After the toughest climb always comes something better.
I have known the joy of seeing the end of a long stage already a stone's throw away and knowing that the rest you deserve is near.
I have learned that if you know how to search, there is always a yellow arrow that shows you the right path.
I have felt anger and even fear walking on the verge of roads packed with vehicles and pure delight walking lonely lanes through lush forests.
I have been relieved to see the tip of a church tower appear among the wheat fields, indicating that the destination is near.
I have changed the face to pure happiness to find the person I love the most (my wife) in the most unexpected moment and the most unexpected place.
I have felt what it is to be alone and enjoy solitude and I have felt what it is to be alone and to be homesick and missing my family.
I have seen that as important as reaching the goal is to enjoy the way to it. The goal is nothing without the path that leads you to it and the path is meaningless if you are not clear about the goal.
And I have discovered that you should not try to find out what your reason is for following the path, because there is never a single reason for following it.
Pilgrims don't need to talk about their reasons for making the way. They just follow it, because they know deep inside that they have to. ¿Why?...sometimes even yourself does not know why. But if the Camino calls you, you will will eventualy discover the reason while walking.
The road has been there for many centuries, and if it calls you, the best thing to do is to go and start by putting one foot forward, and then the other, and then the other again and again...
You will surely discover that the path has something to offer you.
The path is always there. Only you are missing.
Thank you sooo much. I've been going thru this and had no idea why I was feeling so empty and like a loved one has died. Thank you again.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?