Need recommendations for new rucksack

[mikeatspokes]

Hi there, just wondering if anyone has any experience of small rucksacks of around 30l that can pass Ryanair's carry-on hand luggage sizing, 40x25x20cm? I know many rucksacks larger than this will compress down to fit, but don't want to commit until I'm sure they won't charge me extra at the check-in. Unfortunately the Berghaus bag I used on my last Camino had seen better days and I no longer have it, so need to find a replacement for my next adventure.

I have seen a few possibilities but some of these are not available here (in the U.K.) other than online, hence my request for personal recommendations.

Thanks in advance

 

[Bradypus]

I bought one of these earlier this year. Used it on the Portugues, the Ingles and the Frances. Chosen as it is a very close match to the under seat "free" Ryanair allowance but has a comfortable hip belt. Very pleased with it. It will remain my pack of choice for the foreseeable for main season walks. Not big enough for winter gear though. Go Outdoors also sell them.

Technicals Tibet 25 Rucksack | Blacks

£15.00 | A 25-litre rucksack that offers enough space for your...

www.blacks.co.uk

 

[PiesIrlandeses]

40x25x20cm is only 20 litres.

A 30l rucksack will most likely need to checked in.

 

[mikeatspokes]

I bought one of these earlier this year. Used it on the Portugues, the Ingles and the Frances. Chosen as it is a very close match to the under seat "free" Ryanair allowance but has a comfortable hip belt. Very pleased with it. It will remain my pack of choice for the foreseeable for main season walks. Not big enough for winter gear though. Go Outdoors also sell them.

Technicals Tibet 25 Rucksack | Blacks

£15.00 | A 25-litre rucksack that offers enough space for your...

www.blacks.co.uk

Thanks Bradypus, I was looking at the Technicals Glencoe 28l, though I think this is discontinued. Will have to make another trip to Go Outdoors and have a closer look!

 

[trecile]

I understand that you want to save the checked bag fee, but make sure that whatever you buy is comfortable.

 

[mikeatspokes]

40x25x20cm is only 20 litres.

A 30l rucksack will most likely need to checked in.

That's true on the 20l of course, and this is the Ryanair stated capacity, however a larger rucksack can often be compressed into the smaller size, depending on how full it is. I am specifying around 30l because there are few suitable rucksacks available that meet the sizing and are comfortable. The bag I took last year was bigger, but compressed very well. Unfortunately I no longer have it as it was past it's best.

 

[mikeatspokes]

I understand that you want to save the checked bag fee, but make sure that whatever you buy is comfortable.

Thank you trecile, comfort is paramount of course, but I believe it is still possible to have both as I had last year on my first Camino.

 

[Anhalter]

Some guys over at my ultralight forum recommended this Decathlon bag: https://www.decathlon.de/p/rucksack-travel-faltbar-wasserdicht-25-liter/_/R-p-309863?mc=8560421 (german store, but should be available at other Decathlons as well).
But of course you would need a fairly compact and light kit to make things work... 3-4kg tops.

edit: for my taste its missing a hip-strap/belt. but some seem to be fine without.

 

[Tincatinker]

I appreciate that Ryanair can present challenges to the pilgrim that even a grumpy hospitalero on a wet night on the Meseta cannot match. Nonetheless I think I would devote my energies to finding another airline rather than another rucksack. Or just render Caesar his due and sit back and relax.

I’m sure I’ve wasted more time and money on budgeting “budget” airlines than any sensible adult should.

 

[trecile]

Some guys over at my ultralight forum recommended this Decathlon bag: https://www.decathlon.de/p/rucksack-travel-faltbar-wasserdicht-25-liter/_/R-p-309863?mc=8560421 (german store, but should be available at other Decathlons as well).
But of course you would need a fairly compact and light kit to make things work... 3-4kg tops.

I have the smaller version of that backpack, which I love. I use for day hikes on rainy days because it's waterproof.

 

[Robo]

Hi there, just wondering if anyone has any experience of small rucksacks of around 30l that can pass Ryanair's carry-on hand luggage sizing, 40x25x20cm? I know many rucksacks larger than this will compress down to fit, but don't want to commit until I'm sure they won't charge me extra at the check-in. Unfortunately the Berghaus bag I used on my last Camino had seen better days and I no longer have it, so need to find a replacement for my next adventure.

I have seen a few possibilities but some of these are not available here (in the U.K.) other than online, hence my request for personal recommendations.

Thanks in advance

That's always a tough one. I would never try to 'push' the capacity rules just in case someone decided to be very strict about it.

For our next Europe trip, that is likely not a Camino, I have researched the carry on sizes of all the discount airlines that we might use. It will be a kind of flying version of 'back packing' around Europe for a couple of weeks.

I came to the conclusion that the 'free' carry on with some airlines was just too small to be useful. Ryanair being 20L. We don't want to have any checked in luggage as it will slow us down at Airports, and we'll be hoping on and off public transport and want to travel light.

So I looked at the next best option, which as a 'regular' booking that included a 10 kg 44L carry on bag. This is roughly the same across many other discount airlines. So we are planning on a 40L Osprey Travel Pack. That is designed for carry on travel. It has decent straps, hip belt etc.

Our Camino packs, at 24L and 34L would also fail the free Ryanair carry on allowance. They don't really squash down as they have internal frames.

So I would tend to go for the next level of ticket, rather than compromise on my Camino pack.
Really a case of taking what suits best for a Camino or saving €35 on the ticket (in our case).

 

[David]

Thanks Bradypus, I was looking at the Technicals Glencoe 28l, though I think this is discontinued. Will have to make another trip to Go Outdoors and have a closer look!

Technicals is made by the owner of Go Outdoors group and they still sell them, but only in grey now.

Technicals Glencoe 28L Daysack | GO Outdoors

An active daysack, ready to handle any adventure. The Technicals Glencoe 28L Daysack combines tough fabrics with padding to provide long-lasting and comfortable carrying in any environment.

www.gooutdoors.co.uk

Bradypus's Tibet 25 (there is also a 35) is a great pack at a ridiculously low price. Proof that you don't have to spend silly money for a great and practical pack. Well made and so on, like all Technicals, but I wonder if it would be better with side compressions straps (though I may be wrong, I often am). But the design is right for carry-on isn't it? No frame so easily "squeezable"?

There is also the fairly unknown JAM brand - they do a good looking 25, also silly cheap - but like the Glencoe, it too has a rigid frame ...

JAM Air Rucksack Waterproof Hiking Camping Hydrate Backpack

Take to the trails with the JAM Air Rucksack! Comfortable, waterproof and lightweight. Carries all you need for your next great adventure. Available in 2 sizes and a range of colours. Discover lots more outdoor accessories in stock now!

www.xs-stock.co.uk

Re your beloved but now gone Berghaus - have you thought of looking for a newer used one on Ebay?

and .... I don't fly so don't know about this carry-on and cargo hold thing, nor the prices .. but if you are going on Camino in summer have you thought about using the carry-on backpack problem Ryan Air have gifted you to think "minimalist" Camino? - Like this perhaps? - https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/167057085814

Great time to choose a pack - the January sales are coming!!

 

[TravellingMan22]

If you are in UK and have a Sports Direct near you, have a look in there. My local one had a range of sizes, some which are within the size parameters, and were clearly labelled to indicate that. I think the brand was Slazenger so should be of a decent quality. Good prices too. TK Max may be worth a look too. I should be in my local ones tomorrow afternoon UK time so will try and take a look and advise.

 

[mikeatspokes]

Some guys over at my ultralight forum recommended this Decathlon bag: https://www.decathlon.de/p/rucksack-travel-faltbar-wasserdicht-25-liter/_/R-p-309863?mc=8560421 (german store, but should be available at other Decathlons as well).
But of course you would need a fairly compact and light kit to make things work... 3-4kg tops.

edit: for my taste its missing a hip-strap/belt. but some seem to be fine without.

Thanks, but a little too minimal for me! Think I was carrying about 7kg last time and I only had essentials for the most. Compared to some, I was ultra lightweight lol!

 

[mikeatspokes]

I appreciate that Ryanair can present challenges to the pilgrim that even a grumpy hospitalero on a wet night on the Meseta cannot match. Nonetheless I think I would devote my energies to finding another airline rather than another rucksack. Or just render Caesar his due and sit back and relax.

I’m sure I’ve wasted more time and money on budgeting “budget” airlines than any sensible adult should.

You are of course correct Tincatinker, but Ryanair is the only option for me as the flight out is already booked and the only practical choice on return. I have to buy another rucksack as I no longer have the old one or another that's even close to being suitable.

 

[mikeatspokes]

Technicals is made by the owner of Go Outdoors group and they still sell them, but only in grey now.

Technicals Glencoe 28L Daysack | GO Outdoors

An active daysack, ready to handle any adventure. The Technicals Glencoe 28L Daysack combines tough fabrics with padding to provide long-lasting and comfortable carrying in any environment.

www.gooutdoors.co.uk

Bradypus's Tibet 25 (there is also a 35) is a great pack at a ridiculously low price. Proof that you don't have to spend silly money for a great and practical pack. Well made and so on, like all Technicals, but I wonder if it would be better with side compressions straps (though I may be wrong, I often am). But the design is right for carry-on isn't it? No frame so easily "squeezable"?

There is also the fairly unknown JAM brand - they do a good looking 25, also silly cheap - but like the Glencoe, it too has a rigid frame ...

JAM Air Rucksack Waterproof Hiking Camping Hydrate Backpack

Take to the trails with the JAM Air Rucksack! Comfortable, waterproof and lightweight. Carries all you need for your next great adventure. Available in 2 sizes and a range of colours. Discover lots more outdoor accessories in stock now!

www.xs-stock.co.uk

Re your beloved but now gone Berghaus - have you thought of looking for a newer used one on Ebay?

and .... I don't fly so don't know about this carry-on and cargo hold thing, nor the prices .. but if you are going on Camino in summer have you thought about using the carry-on backpack problem Ryan Air have gifted you to think "minimalist" Camino? - Like this perhaps? - https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/167057085814

Great time to choose a pack - the January sales are coming!!

Thanks David. I guess I was really hoping for a recommendation from someone who has actually taken a similar rucksack through the check-in. Framed rucksacks are as you say more of an issue when it comes to compressing them, but there just aren't that many options for frameless, as my Berghaus was. Whilst that particular bag worked fine for the Francés last year, it wasn't ideal especially in the heat and rain, and I wouldn't want to use one on another Camino. The JAM I hadn't heard of, but again, I don't want to order online something I haven't seen in person or can be certain of. Going 'minimalist' isn't an option as I am doing other things other than the walking on my trip to Portugal, and I'll be away for some time. Time to peruse the sales definitely.

 

[mikeatspokes]

If you are in UK and have a Sports Direct near you, have a look in there. My local one had a range of sizes, some which are within the size parameters, and were clearly labelled to indicate that. I think the brand was Slazenger so should be of a decent quality. Good prices too. TK Max may be worth a look too. I should be in my local ones tomorrow afternoon UK time so will try and take a look and advise.

Yes, once the xmas holidays are out of the way, I'll have to trawl the Sports Direct, Go Outdoors and Decathlon stores! I'm wary of the cheaper brands that Mike Ashley's group have re-invented as they are often made to meet a price, not necessarily quality. Some of the brands I have been looking at are only available (other than online) in the EU or US, so I am unable to check them in person, e.g. Millet, Lafuma, Finisterre, MLD, etc, I don't mind paying more for the right bag, In the end it may just come down to me forking out the extra to take a larger bag on the flights, I just don't want to pay Ryanair more than I have to!

 

[TravellingMan22]

Yes, once the xmas holidays are out of the way, I'll have to trawl the Sports Direct, Go Outdoors and Decathlon stores! I'm wary of the cheaper brands that Mike Ashley's group have re-invented as they are often made to meet a price, not necessarily quality. Some of the brands I have been looking at are only available (other than online) in the EU or US, so I am unable to check them in person, e.g. Millet, Lafuma, Finisterre, MLD, etc, I don't mind paying more for the right bag, In the end it may just come down to me forking out the extra to take a larger bag on the flights, I just don't want to pay Ryanair more than I have to!

Sure I tend to shop at the cheaper end as I travel light so maybe nowhere near the quality you require. I will have a look though.

Re Ryanair, well I travel on them at least ten times a year and have been for ages, and I find them to be very good. I can only recall 1 delay over >1 hour and their punctuality, regularity and baggage stats are pretty much up there with pretty much all the European carriers.

 

[mikeatspokes]

Re Ryanair, well I travel on them at least ten times a year and have been for ages, and I find them to be very good. I can only recall 1 delay over >1 hour and their punctuality, regularity and baggage stats are pretty much up there with pretty much all the European carriers.

I have no problems with them as an airline, just find their sales practices too pushy for what should really be a relatively simple booking. Then again many online stores do the same things, utilizing 'dark patterns' to get you to spend a bit more on things you don't need!

 

[Bradypus]

I have no problems with them as an airline, just find their sales practices too pushy for what should really be a relatively simple booking.

That is annoying but I find it an acceptable price to pay for some remarkably cheap travel. In November last year I flew from Bristol to Gran Canaria to walk the Camino there. The fare for the 4 hour 3,000km journey was about the same as my travel costs from my home in west Wales for the 160km to the airport in Bristol.

 

[Hans-Georg Goebel]

Hi there, just wondering if anyone has any experience of small rucksacks of around 30l that can pass Ryanair's carry-on hand luggage sizing, 40x25x20cm? I know many rucksacks larger than this will compress down to fit, but don't want to commit until I'm sure they won't charge me extra at the check-in. Unfortunately the Berghaus bag I used on my last Camino had seen better days and I no longer have it, so need to find a replacement for my next adventure.

I have seen a few possibilities but some of these are not available here (in the U.K.) other than online, hence my request for personal recommendations.

Thanks in advance

You spend hundreds of pounds to walk the Camino and scrimp to save a few pounds instead of not having to give up the backpack that really suits you and is comfortable to wear

 

[1man2dogs]

Hi there, just wondering if anyone has any experience of small rucksacks of around 30l that can pass Ryanair's carry-on hand luggage sizing, 40x25x20cm? I know many rucksacks larger than this will compress down to fit, but don't want to commit until I'm sure they won't charge me extra at the check-in. Unfortunately the Berghaus bag I used on my last Camino had seen better days and I no longer have it, so need to find a replacement for my next adventure.

I have seen a few possibilities but some of these are not available here (in the U.K.) other than online, hence my request for personal recommendations.

Thanks in advance

I have a decathlon 30L Quechua MH500. I've used it with RyanAir, EasyJet and Vueling as carry on without a problem.

 

[Bothydave]

Hi there, just wondering if anyone has any experience of small rucksacks of around 30l that can pass Ryanair's carry-on hand luggage sizing, 40x25x20cm? I know many rucksacks larger than this will compress down to fit, but don't want to commit until I'm sure they won't charge me extra at the check-in. Unfortunately the Berghaus bag I used on my last Camino had seen better days and I no longer have it, so need to find a replacement for my next adventure.

I have seen a few possibilities but some of these are not available here (in the U.K.) other than online, hence my request for personal recommendations.

Thanks in advance

I use a 40ltr Alpkit bag that fits in overhead lockers on all flights. Alpkit now make this as a 45litre bag so worth checking the dimensions
Reputable dealers always provide the dimensions

 

[Bothydave]

That is annoying but I find it an acceptable price to pay for some remarkably cheap travel. In November last year I flew from Bristol to Gran Canaria to walk the Camino there. The fare for the 4 hour 3,000km journey was about the same as my travel costs from my home in west Wales for the 160km to the airport in Bristol.

That’s Rip Off Britain for you!

 

[trecile]

I have a decathlon 30L Quechua MH500. I've used it with RyanAir, EasyJet and Vueling as carry on without a problem.

Does it fit under the seat?

I use a 40ltr Alpkit bag that fits in overhead lockers on all flights. Alpkit now make this as a 45litre bag so worth checking the dimensions
Reputable dealers always provide the dimensions

It sounds like @mikeatspokes is looking for a backpack that will fit under the seat to avoid Ryanair's overhead bin or checked bag charge. Correct me if I'm wrong @mikeatspokes.

 

[RibbonRomanceAuthor]

I understand that you want to save the checked bag fee, but make sure that whatever you buy is comfortable.

Yes to this. If it doesn't work on the Camino, it will matter little that you didn't have to pay fees to get it there. I recommend getting measured for fit and going from there. In the US, I was fitted at REI and found a 26L Deuter.