Like some posters already said here : a good albergue is not only a matter of lodging only but also of the people ( hospitaleros and voluntarios ) working there. And the lovely people in the villages of course.
Here follows my very subjective list.
Pamplona : Casa Paderborn run by the german confraternity of St.James : a very warm welcome with fruit juice and a cookie. Warm and disciplined at the same time. Spotlessly clean and lights only on at 6.30 accompanied with nice music. Next to the river and the nautical school. Very peaceful.Sieglinde and Dieter had a nice word for everyone, good advice and a motherly cuddle from Sieglinde.
Zubiri : Zaldiko, private one. Clean but cramped habitaciones and the owner was correct but nothing more.
Obanos : I heard that some people find the owner distant but I liked his style : gentle and correct. Lots of room, minimal but clean sanitary accomodation and a nice little private library. Thanks also to Inaki and his mum for the lovely dinner at their bar.
Villatuerta : closed at that time so headed to Estella.
Estella : albergue parroquial! Lovely volunteers and nice vibe in the albergue, communal meal. Small but again spotless sanitary installation. Observation : lots of people still think that donativo means free!!! Sad to see how some people ( and yes those with money !!! ) don't give ANYTHING!!!
Villamayor de Monjardin : the private one from Oasis Trails. Ok accomodation but the volunteers were a bit too pushy for my liking : trying to convince you to attend their prayings. Again, a very personal review.
Torres del Rio : new private one called Casa Mariela. Disastrous meeting with a very very drunken mexican who was drinking himself into a coma. The young employee dealt with it in a very swift way!! Thank you!!!
Ventosa : private one. I read that some people found the hospitaleros very strict but I liked them. Bit like my favourite teacher : strict but honest! Very clean and warm atmoshpere too. People came in late and already owner put extra matrasses on the floor so he drove the latecomers with his car to the next village.
Azofra : municipal with the double rooms. Nice facilities and a great kitchen!
Redecilla del Camino : municipal with donativo for albergue and dinner ( made by lady of village ). Really nice feeling, gentle lady and again everything spotlessly clean.
Bar/bakery/shop was outstanding!
Tosantos : parroquial : LOVELY!!! Gentle, kind and warm. So different from the one at Oasis trails. Minimum but clean facilities but the gentleness and warmth made up for this.
Again people : donativo does NOT mean for free!!!
San Juan de Ortega : aaaaaarrrgh! the worst : humid and cold. The hospitalero at the moment was really unfriendly and uncaring. Sanitary facilities ??? disgusting.
Burgos : the municipal. What can I say? We cried from contentment after that night before. Friendly and swift welcome. Maybe a bit big and anonymous but I didn't mind.
Hornillas del Camino : municipal. Again very humid and an uncaring hospitalero. Owner of only bar is also mayor and owner of albergue. Grumpy chap!
Castrojeriz : private one Casa Nostra. Lovely gentle owner, wooden floors, very clean bathrooms, nice little library. One of my favourites!
Fromista : municipal. Just ok, not bad not very good. Clean but lots of noise with people coming in late.
Carrion de los Condes : Espiritu Santo : individual beds in superclean surroundings. Everything a little antique but well kept! Very nice. Also thnaks to the people at the local centro de salud for attending to my small medical issue!
Calzadilla de la Cueza : hmm average clean but the hospitelera at that time Judith was so gentle and nice!
Sahagun : municipal Cluny. Clean but that dark wood everywhere was a bit depressing. Also my quarrel with an elderly german ( till today I do not have a clue why he started yelling to me ) didn't make it a happy stay.
Mansilla de las Mulas : the lovely municipal with the nicest hospitalera ever. Warm and funny, very attentive ( she is a hell of a good nurse ). Loved it!!!!
Leon : private at the Benedictenesses : cramped rooms, with all that human warmth we did not need a sleeping bag. BUT, lovely nice volunteers who were so helpful and gentle and funny. Thank you!!! And again the story about the donativo...SIGH...
Villadangos de Paramo : municipal, also one to forget... I had my doubts about the mattrasses. Hospitalera was not interested. Cold surroundings.
Rabanal del Camino : Gaucelmo : perfect. Teamoment, disposable sheets. Pat, hospitalera and a wonderful and lovely lady.
Molinaseca : new one the Santa Marina : very spacious and clean but missed " soul ". An anonymous feeling. Also the atmosphere changed here : more and more people " rushing " and more people coming with car , parked it around corner and came in with a legitimate credencial!!!!
Cacabelos : municipal with the double rooms around the church. Loved it!! Clean facilities and I shared the room with someone I knew.
O' Cebreiro : Xunta one : big but clean and perfectly run, nice hospitalera too. Again a lot of partygoers and loud people.
Vega De Valcarce: left the municipal because of horrible state of beds and checked into pension. Say no more...
Tricastela : Aitzenea : very nice hospitalera, spotlessly clean rooms with wooden floors, fully equipped kitchen, disposable sheets, cosy living room. Free internet.
Sarria : los Blasones : Tita the owner is really friendly, keeps it all very clean, good kitchen. Again less respect towards end of Camino between people.
Portomarin : Ultreia : brand new, obviously private but the owners have a big heart, always there and clean up between every shower! Again lots of people who made reservations and came in with neat suitcases and a hairblower!! Nevertheless : liked it. Good kitchen facilities too.
Ribadiso de Baixa : Xunta next to river. Clean and spacious but the wooden doors made a hell of noise during the night. So called closing time is a laugh because people kept coming in after twelve!
35 days
Camino Frances and I treated myself to 6 hostals or pensions during that time. First I thought that I was cheating but now I know that I needed this privacy from time to time.