Richard Ward
Member
- Time of past OR future Camino
- Future: April 2024; Past: Frances, Norte, Madrid.
Remove ads on the forum by becoming a donating member. More here. |
---|
An interesting idea. It seems to me that it would be quite possible, even if it would be rather unusual for most forum members. Perhaps you need to be asking this where there are more likely to be outdoors enthusiasts who might have done this rather than trying to get information from the Camino oriented members of this forum.I realize it is traditional for many non-Spaniards to start in SJPP, but do some start at the French border via a round-trip from Roncesvalles? I think you would get most of the views, without the hassle/expense of trying to get to SJPP, plus you would avoid about 800 m of vertical climb. I think the trip may also be safer in some regards, as you can see what you are getting into, and can just retreat if conditions get bad.
Any suggestions would be very much appreciated. If I do this, my preferences would be to:
1) Stash most of my pack somewhere in Roncesvalles for the daytrip (does anyone watch packs?)
2) Hike a different route up than back, preferably steeper up, and less steep back (suggested trails?)
3) While I am very used to hiking alone (e.g., 2000+ miles of the Appalachian Trail), company would be welcome, likely on April 23rd.
Thanks!
Sounds like a lot of hassle to avoid a few kilometers over the Pyrenees.
You can get a bus to SJPDP from Pamplona. If you want to avoid the steepness of the Napoleon route, just take the ValCarlos. It's a nice walk.
Never did the AT, but did some backpacking in my younger days and days and nights with a ruck on in the military. I think you will quickly discover that the Camino Frances is really not a hike. More of a walk with a backpack on. You do so much of the walking on improved and semi-improved surfaces and crash in a warm bed every night. I never approached it the same way I did a hike.Valcarlos was my original plan Mark. But I want to do the Napoleon Route for the views, and there is a danger that it will be closed on the 23rd. I'm just throwing out the option of starting in Ronce, and still getting to hike "all the way" across Spain (assuming an ocean finish). There is some precedent for this on the Appalachian Trail -- one has to hike up a mountain (Springer in Georgia, Katahdin in Maine) to actually start the trail. It seems natural for me to do that as well on the Camino, though I am guessing now it is almost never done. I thought about the taxi idea, but since there is a reasonable loop that gets you part of the way to the French border, you can have "fun" in both directions. But HYOH/HYOC I guess.
I realize it is traditional for many non-Spaniards to start in SJPP, but do some start at the French border via a round-trip from Roncesvalles? I think you would get most of the views, without the hassle/expense of trying to get to SJPP, plus you would avoid about 800 m of vertical climb. I think the trip may also be safer in some regards, as you can see what you are getting into, and can just retreat if conditions get bad.
Any suggestions would be very much appreciated. If I do this, my preferences would be to:
1) Stash most of my pack somewhere in Roncesvalles for the daytrip (does anyone watch packs?)
2) Hike a different route up than back, preferably steeper up, and less steep back (suggested trails?)
3) While I am very used to hiking alone (e.g., 2000+ miles of the Appalachian Trail), company would be welcome, likely on April 23rd.
Thanks!
It's mainly the weather Robo. Temperatures on the 23rd and/or 24th at altitude will likely drop down below freezing, and rain/sleet/snow/ice is predicted. I want the views of the "top" of the Pyrenees, but am not confident that they will be worth risking the Napoleon Route from SJPP.
As an FYI, you meet A LOT of hikers/pilgrims hiking counter to the normal flow -- one day hiking near the southern terminus of the Appalachian Trail I counted well over 100 hikers when hiking against the flow, while a normal day hiking in the direction of the pack I would often see zero hikers.
I'm surprised that this hasn't been done before by a forum member, but anyway, I have been one that very much believes in HYOH.
And yes I do tend to overthink things, but only the start of this one. I'm just going to go with what feels good/right after the first day.
Hope to see you in SdC in May, and Buen Camino!
. I'm glad that this forum is much more friendly -- which is what I would expect from a Pilgrimage site vs. a hiking site.
IF I go this route, I am thinking that I won't really start my Camino until I get to the French border, then walk down to Roncesvalles as a pilgrim, get my credential, go to the Pilgrim's Mass on Saturday night (it "counts"), sleep in the albergue, wake up (if I get to sleep that is...) and continue to walk as a pilgrim.
Hi Katharina. I have looked at that shuttle -- http://www.expressbourricot.com/persons-transport/ (15 Euro to Croix Thibault) -- but my main issue is the weather. I could get up there and be pretty much alone, in unfamiliar territory, and in horrible conditions (weather at 200 m does not equal weather at 1200 m) -- a jarring start to a very long journey.
ain't a real hump unless you done it with 60-80 pounds of gear, shelter half, weapon, ammo and a base plate for a mortarOh no, definitely not treating this Camino like a hike, but the inherent danger in the SJPP to Roncesvalles in April makes me treat THAT section like a hike. IF I go this route, I am thinking that I won't really start my Camino until I get to the French border, then walk down to Roncesvalles as a pilgrim, get my credential, go to the Pilgrim's Mass on Saturday night (it "counts"), sleep in the albergue, wake up (if I get to sleep that is...) and continue to walk as a pilgrim.
As an aside, the comparable Appalachian Trail forum has similar debates -- e.g., thru-hikers vs. section hikers & hike the eight-mile Springer Mountain Access Trail vs. getting driven to Springer Mountain to start the trail -- but the debate is quite a bit more salty. I'm glad that this forum is much more friendly -- which is what I would expect from a Pilgrimage site vs. a hiking site.
If you start in Roncesvalles, you will also feel like a Pilgrim as the town is also full of them!Sorry I can't resist
IF you start at SJPDP. You will 'feel' like a Pilgrim from the moment you arriveThe town is full of them!
.
I realize it is traditional for many non-Spaniards to start in SJPP, but do some start at the French border via a round-trip from Roncesvalles? I think you would get most of the views, without the hassle/expense of trying to get to SJPP, plus you would avoid about 800 m of vertical climb. I think the trip may also be safer in some regards, as you can see what you are getting into, and can just retreat if conditions get bad.
Any suggestions would be very much appreciated. If I do this, my preferences would be to:
1) Stash most of my pack somewhere in Roncesvalles for the daytrip (does anyone watch packs?)
2) Hike a different route up than back, preferably steeper up, and less steep back (suggested trails?)
3) While I am very used to hiking alone (e.g., 2000+ miles of the Appalachian Trail), company would be welcome, likely on April 23rd.
Thanks!
A lot of SJPP fans here. I'm starting there if weather is OK (and it looks like it might be improving). Fingers crossed.Not much to look at after you cross into Spain on that day. If beautiful views are your thing, don't miss them by not starting in SJPP.
You will love it. I never understand those who suggest starting in Roncesvalles. You get to walk into Spain, experience gorgeous views, cross a whole country, share that challenge with people who will keep bumping into. Knowing I could walk that stretch gave me a lot of satisfaction and whenevwr I wanted to "cheat" further on I would just remind myself of having been able to walk that day so I knew I could walk anything else. Enjoy it, but only if it is safe.A lot of SJPP fans here. I'm starting there if weather is OK (and it looks like it might be improving). Fingers crossed.
A lot of SJPP fans here. I'm starting there if weather is OK (and it looks like it might be improving). Fingers crossed.
If you start in Roncesvalles, you will also feel like a Pilgrim as the town is also full of them!
Wonderful!! having now made your decision will take a load off. Be sure to check in at the Pilgrim Office in St. Jean. As others have said, they can apprise you of the weather conditions, give you help with accommodations and answer any questions. You will discover a whole family of friends in St. Jean….and will stay in contact with them along the way, depending on everyones walking pace. I envy you…..I need to wait until 2017 to return. Again, Buean Camino Richard.A lot of SJPP fans here. I'm starting there if weather is OK (and it looks like it might be improving). Fingers crossed.
I find yr.no the most reliable long term (and short) weather forecast. It even manages to predict the Irish weather correctly - most of the time.Hi Katharina. I have looked at that shuttle -- http://www.expressbourricot.com/persons-transport/ (15 Euro to Croix Thibault) -- but my main issue is the weather. I could get up there and be pretty much alone, in unfamiliar territory, and in horrible conditions (weather at 200 m does not equal weather at 1200 m) -- a jarring start to a very long journey.
I was planning on taking the steep route up -- I think that would involve going up the steep GRT7 to Lepoeder, joining up with GR12 to hike to French border, hopefully getting snacks from the man there, then turning around and taking GR12 back to Roncesvalles via the Ibaneta pass. Total distance would be 18 km.
But maybe the weather forecast will be great, I can get a taxi share from Pamplona to SJPP in the early afternoon on the 22nd, and can then take the Napoleon route on the 23rd after sleeping off my jetlag.
Thanks for all of the tips, especially the weather links!
If you are fit and willing I think the start in SJPP is worth the hassle, though a lot of people starting off in SJPP complain about picking up injuries over the first arduous day, it is tough going but worth it if you are fit enough. Good luck. PatI realize it is traditional for many non-Spaniards to start in SJPP, but do some start at the French border via a round-trip from Roncesvalles? I think you would get most of the views, without the hassle/expense of trying to get to SJPP, plus you would avoid about 800 m of vertical climb. I think the trip may also be safer in some regards, as you can see what you are getting into, and can just retreat if conditions get bad.
Any suggestions would be very much appreciated. If I do this, my preferences would be to:
1) Stash most of my pack somewhere in Roncesvalles for the daytrip (does anyone watch packs?)
2) Hike a different route up than back, preferably steeper up, and less steep back (suggested trails?)
3) While I am very used to hiking alone (e.g., 2000+ miles of the Appalachian Trail), company would be welcome, likely on April 23rd.
Thanks!
I'm going to give a brief report as I am a bit rundown after 3 fun days of hiking and 2 nearly sleepless nights.Given the diverse views Richard, I would like to see a post about your first day
Buen comino
Definitely do-able...but heres the rub. The first day of the Camino over the Pyrenees is one of self confirmation and you would be missing the joy of sharing the excitement of those people who are not hikers per se. The conversation at the communal dinner at the hotel will be based on that excitement. Last time I did the CF I was forced to start in Pamplona by my airlines' inability to deliver me and my backpack in the same week. I missed the thrill of the challenge and the sense of accomplishment provided by the Pyrenees Crossing. Just sayin.I realize it is traditional for many non-Spaniards to start in SJPP, but do some start at the French border via a round-trip from Roncesvalles? I think you would get most of the views, without the hassle/expense of trying to get to SJPP, plus you would avoid about 800 m of vertical climb. I think the trip may also be safer in some regards, as you can see what you are getting into, and can just retreat if conditions get bad.
Any suggestions would be very much appreciated. If I do this, my preferences would be to:
1) Stash most of my pack somewhere in Roncesvalles for the daytrip (does anyone watch packs?)
2) Hike a different route up than back, preferably steeper up, and less steep back (suggested trails?)
3) While I am very used to hiking alone (e.g., 2000+ miles of the Appalachian Trail), company would be welcome, likely on April 23rd.
Thanks!
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?