- Time of past OR future Camino
- Francés x 5, Le Puy x 2, Arles, Tours, Norte, Madrid, Via de la Plata, Portuguese, Primitivo
Remove ads on the forum by becoming a donating member. More here. |
---|
Thanks Kanga, for the advice, saw a podiatrist early in the piece, they told me to get the merrils - if weight permits I think I will buy a pair of runners anyway and take them. Cheers.
Without a doubt I DO NOT recommend hiking boots. I watched so many people with hiking boots struggling with blisters. I walked 30 days from st jean this summer with my wife. My wife and I didn't get one blister and hiked with trail running shoes. Brooks Cascadia Trailrunning shoes were what I used and absolutely loved them. I had other pains on the camino but blisters were not one of my physical problems. Also invest in some good quality socks. Hope that helps
- Gabe
My solution: 100% wool socks, proper fitting boots that don't slip and slide on your foot but provide room to wiggle toes and "spread out" a little. And attention to your walking style: If you are pigeon toed or duck footed, the tendency to slide sideways when stepping can add to the friction that causes the blister. Or not, depending.... And the type of shoe, light weight or heavy can add to the heat buildup. Good ventilation (gortex type?) is important. I had a friend who swore by his $100. silk sock liners inside Thorlo socks. . Used an old, well worn in boot. Blister free, comfortable until he got a prodigious blister after 25 days on the trail. I was blister free the whole 35 days we were out. As the carny barker sez, ya pays yer money an' ya takes yer cherz.To add to what I have said before, today I walked 11 kms in preparation for my journey. I felt good. No groin pains, no shin splints, everything felt great. Was going to book the flight!
Until about the 5th km. Then I felt my foot beginning to blister. But I was 5 kms from home, so I kept walking my circular route. At about 9 kms, I flet the other foot begin to act up.
Upon arriving at home, my right foot has a blister about the size of a quarter, on the left foot, half of the bottom of the foot is a blister, plus another huge blister on the left side of the left foot.
Darn, Darn, Darn. This will set me back at least a week. At least I will have some extra time to concentrate on buying new footwear. :wink:
Blister advise, anyone?
All - I have read so many posts and various articles about the Camino that I'm sure of one thing: There are as many opinions as there are people!Still, I hear that October is the rainiest month for the last 125 miles (200km) of the Camino Frances into Santiago. I walk and hike a lot in Utah, but usually not in the rain or mud. I do not like boots (too heavy and more spots for blisters) but I don't like wet feet either. Looking for some opinions on waterproof shoes (I really like my Merrills w the non-slip sole) and am hoping to hear some feedback about the wet-factor. Thanks!
I realize this post is older, but wanted to put in my 2 cents for Chaco's hiking sandals. LOVE, LOVE them. They provided plenty of support with very few blistersI have read a lot of conflicting information - some say a good pair of hiking boots is required, especially if you are going in the Winter or Spring. Other sites say that hiking boots are overkill and that hiking shoes, or even a good pair of running shoes are sufficient. What do you think :?:
With regard to Vaseline (interesting thread, by the way), does anyone know if this can be bought in Santiago? I'm starting my walk there and because I'm travelling with cabin baggage only, I can't take any liquids greater than 100ml. I don't think 100ml of Vaseline will go very far so I'll be looking at buying it on arrival in Spain (unless I can get it in the departure lounge as I leave but I don't know if they'll have it).
Thanks.
I bought Timberland boots for the first time last fall, as I could not find anything else that would fit and be comfortable. They are more lightweight than my previous boots, but give good support. I have not yet walked the camino with them. I'm going in the fall, October-November. I have noticed that they are fully lined and seem quite warm, at least, warm enough for a Calgary winter. I don't know whether someone from southern California would find them hot in a Spanish summer. You have had good experience with Timberland boots, giving the fit and support that you need, so that should be your main criterion. I am also taking a pair of lightweight shoes (Nikes) for city and possibly pavement wear. It is a nuisance to carry an extra pair of footwear, but I remind myself that the camino is a very long walk and footwear is the number one essential.
I think there is a BIG MOVE to adopt new technologies by the shoe/book companies to blur the disctinctions between "light hiking" and "trail running" boots/shoes.There is much that has been written in the Ultralight hiking community state side about the benefits of good fitting trail shoes (in appropriate terrain) with a flexible sole that allows the foot and ankle to articulate as they are intended to. When the shoe flex in concert with the feet the chances of blisters reduces. It will also give you an opportunity to build strong feet.
I picked up a pair of LaSportiva Wildcats, the non Gore-tex version. Great traction, cushioning and ventilation.
Buen Camino
I'm testing the same LaSportiva, but I got the version "mid" with the soft rasied collar. It offers zero ankle support, but the "mid" soft cuff does a nice job of keeping gravel out of my shoe. I have other low walking/hiking shoes and my main gripe with them is gravel getting into the shoe. I do find it to be very breathable and light with plenty of cushion to protect the bottoms of my feet from impact.Which ever one you choose pick a good one the best you can afford, but it's true you don't have to spend a fortune to get a good one, but again the last thing you need is having your shoes come apart during the camino. Fit is very important so when buying your new shoes do so after a long day on your feet with the same sock that will be using, get 1/2 to 1 size larger then normal your feet will grow. I for one like the low cut lightweight breathable shoes with a good solid thick sole the impact of your feet on the ground its equal to 1 1/2 to 3 times your body weight with the pack. ( I'm testing the new la sportiva soround gore Tex) I find that the more you walk with low cut shoes the more you ankles gets stronger therefore you will be less chances of twisting of your ankle. And remember 1 lb on your feet its 5 on your back
Zzotte
After reading hundreds of posts, it seems like the person who wrote that there as many opinions as people is right, regarding shoes v. boots, and I'm still trying to figure out what is best for me.
There are thousands of people out there wearing boots and shoes of all sorts, there are even more variations in path conditions, weather, foot eccentricities, and style choices. There is no universal answer - you cannot boil this down to one general statement that identifies the perfect shoe, even for you alone. Make your best guess on the basis of the season when you plan to walk, the route, and what your feet feel good in! Whatever you get will not be the best shoe/boot for every situation.I ask the group, how often do these conditions occur and how important are the shoes in those two situations in El Camino?
I think a boot gives protection to the ankle ,the footbed and sole of a proper trekking boot which is built for distance and carrying weight for a 4 or 5 week walk. Buen CaminoI have read a lot of conflicting information - some say a good pair of hiking boots is required, especially if you are going in the Winter or Spring. Other sites say that hiking boots are overkill and that hiking shoes, or even a good pair of running shoes are sufficient. What do you think :?:
People who prefer boots mention they are better to avoid an ankle twist because--and they are absolutely right--an injury would end your camino, but what is really the frequency of those injuries? I don't think I recall one person saying they had to stop because of an ankle twist.
Another argument is boots are better for walking on mud or stuff coming from animals, as well as climbing up and down steep slopes and rocky ground. And I ask the group, how often do these conditions occur and how important are the shoes in those two situations in El Camino?
We favour Hi-Tec which are wide fitting. For lacing for a high instep I suggest that you ask jennyH about David's lacing technique. We have usually just used the Hi-Tec original insoles but after this year's Camino I bought adjustable insoles from Millets (UK) for my old boots. With my new boots I have stayed with the supplied insoles.OK I did not read every post so my apologies in advance.
I have 2 questions: shoe width, I have a wide foot, with a high instep so need to accommodate these potential problems. Which brand of shoe (generic term) provides the widest last?; second did you go with just the supplied innersole/padding or did you replace these with an alternative?
Socks - one pair or two? I have been a supporter of the two-sock brigade for some years, but would welcome your experiences.
As I do not expect to return to the Camino until May 2017 there is plenty of time to get a solution. Thanks in advance!
Thanks Tia - yes am aware of David's lacing technique and agree it does provide a measure of relief of the lace pressure. I already use a similar technique.We favour Hi-Tec which are wide fitting. For lacing for a high instep I suggest that you ask jennyH about David's lacing technique.
shoe width, I have a wide foot, with a high instep so need to accommodate these potential problems. Which brand of shoe (generic term) provides the widest last?; second did you go with just the supplied innersole/padding or did you replace these with an alternative?
Thank you David, what are the proper socks? CaneadeaHi Tim
Pretty interesting question and responses you have received, and here are my experiences.
I had a pair of boots that were broken in, but when I walked in the Himalayas, I got blisters very quickly.
I walked Hadrian's Wall last year, but this time, I spent money on good socks, and I did not have a problem.
In August, I replaced them with a light weight walking boot and took them straight out for a 39 Klm walk and with proper walking socks, I had no problems.
Yesterday, I debuted a low cut walking shoe and did 33 Klm's of walking in the mud and once again, no blisters.
What I have found is that having proper walking socks are the only way to go
David
awesome thanks, CCompeed Anti-Blister Stick contains:
Hydrogenated vegetable oil, Cetyl alcohol, Parfum, Linalool, Limonene, Hexyl Cinnamal, butylphenyl methylpropional, Hydroxyisohexyl 3-Cyclohexene carboxaldehyde. [all the additives are basically scents]
Crisco hydrogenated vegetable oil
Since its introduction in 1911, Crisco® has revolutionized the way food is prepared and the way it tastes. From being the first shortening product made entirely of vegetable oil to creating the first cooking oil that was promoted for its light taste, Crisco has been making life in the kitchen more delicious for years.
Sportslick was created by combining Petrolatum with Silicone for long lasting waterproof protection, then adding the leading antifungal agent, Tolnaftate with healing ingredients, Aloe, Vitamin E, C, and natural plant extracts.
Soothing Aloe, Antioxidant vitamins A and E, and other natural ingredients moisturize and rejuvenates your skin.
Created by a physician, this unique formula combines the proven antifungal (Tolnaftate) and a popular antibacterial (Triclosan) to guard against infection.
Easy to apply to your feet, legs, thigh, groin, underarms and neck, Sportslick stays where you put it! It won't come off until you wash it off with soap.Sportslick
Contains:
The leading antibacterial, Triclosan. The finest grade Petrolatum was chosen because it is the most effective lubricant available. It is used safely in hundreds of skin products and medications. It is non-comedogenic and hypoallergenic. Sportslick has been proven not to harm wetsuits or athletic equipment.
Silicone - binds to the skin for long lasting waterproof protection
Petrolatum - a proven safe lubricant and moisturizer
Polymers - for a slippery feel and a lasting glide
Tolnaftate 1% - the leading antifungal agent
Aloe - plant extract that heals and moisturizes skin
Vitamin E - antioxidant that helps Vitamin E work more effectively
Soybean Oil - plant extract that repairs and rejuvenates the skin
Natural Oil Fragrance - vanilla almond oil
Triclosan - popular antibacterial
Vaseline® Petroleum Jelly is a mixture of mineral oils, paraffin and microcrystalline waxes that, when blended together, create something remarkable - a smooth jelly that has a melting point just above body temperature. The result - it literally melts into skin, flowing into the spaces between cells and the gaps in our lipid barrier. Once there, it re-solidifies, locking itself in place.
Vaseline® Petroleum Jelly serves two functions: First it helps keep the outside world out - it protects skin from the effects of weather and exposure. Second, it acts like a sealant to help keep the inside world in - it forms an occlusive barrier to the natural water loss of our skin. So skin that is dry and chapped is protected from drying elements, enabling skin-softening moisture to build up naturally from inside the skin itself.
Bag Balm:
8 Hydroxyquinoline Sulfate (0.3% in a Petrolatum, Lanolin Base)
Hydropel:
Active Ingredient: Dimethicone 30%
Other Ingredients: Petrolatum, aluminum starch octenylsuccinate.
PICK THE ONE YOU THINK IS LIKELY TO WORK BEST!!
I walked Camino Del Norte all the way from Irun to Santiago in 35 days last April-May. Not a single blister or any other problems with my feet, nothing at all.I have read a lot of conflicting information - some say a good pair of hiking boots is required, especially if you are going in the Winter or Spring. Other sites say that hiking boots are overkill and that hiking shoes, or even a good pair of running shoes are sufficient. What do you think :?:
Every Farmacia has Vaseline tubes.With regard to Vaseline (interesting thread, by the way), does anyone know if this can be bought in Santiago? I'm starting my walk there and because I'm travelling with cabin baggage only, I can't take any liquids greater than 100ml. I don't think 100ml of Vaseline will go very far so I'll be looking at buying it on arrival in Spain (unless I can get it in the departure lounge as I leave but I don't know if they'll have it).
Thanks.
So here's an interesting experience: I took my hikng shoes back to the shop the other day because there seems to be an air bubble in the heel of one of them. I bought them for the Camino de Madrid next year, and I've been wearing them almost continually since the summer. But while they're being inspected, I've been wearing my hiking boots again, and yesterday as I was walking into town and back (a total of around 8km) it felt as if the boots were propelling me forward. I'm not sure how to describe it: the closest I can get is like walking on a travelator.
Both the shoes and the boots are Meindls, by the way.
I wore hiking boots (Meindl) on my first camino and I will never ever do the same mistake again!
Is there a link describing different lacing techniques? Thanks.@Nanumea
You might also look into different lacing techniques to, f.e., keeping your foot moving too much in the boots and/or to give a wide arch that bit more of space. It is really amazing what you can do to make a boot more comfortable with the right lacing techniques. Buen Camino, SY
You might find Ian's Lacing site helpful.Is there a link describing different lacing techniques? Thanks.
Is there a link describing different lacing techniques? Thanks.
Sturdy Leather Breathable (no waterproof membrane) shoes, about 1 size larger than usual.
I replace the laces with 2 or 3 mm elastic cord. I find it so much more comfortable than laces when feet get hot and expand on long days.
I used Noene Shock absorbing insoles. I walked a coupe of days without them under my regular insoles and had sore knees. I highly recommend these, I never hike without them now and never get knee pain.
I tried Bamboo Socks too, they soak up too much moisture and feel like the shoe is a size too small, they also take too long to dry.
After trying lots of socks I ended up with a thin Organic Cotton by 'Mund' ( I think) that I still use now.
For me synthetic socks just made my feet sweat too much ....
I also take the insoles out and get your hand inside the shoe to get all the bits of stone and grit out every night
SteveView attachment 27577
I don't quite understand what your specific issue/question is.Hello amigos, would you kindly provide your opinion on my specific shoes issue?
I am planning to walk (fast) on the camino francès in oct and nov this year.
While I would love to just bring along my trusted trail running sneakers (Nike wildhorse 3 GTX) and no other pair of shoes, I am however worried as to how they would stand the bad weather, even with gaiters for snow and heavy rain conditions.
The pro's in favor of this specific choice is that I get no blisters at all that way, they are also light and supposedly waterproof.
Of course lateral support is minimal and they dont like to be dragged in pools of mud.
Thx for ur time!
I have read a lot of conflicting information - some say a good pair of hiking boots is required, especially if you are going in the Winter or Spring. Other sites say that hiking boots are overkill and that hiking shoes, or even a good pair of running shoes are sufficient. What do you think :?:
Can you please let me know what brand/type of socks you found?I must quote myself, because this is so funny. Exactly one year ago I wrote that post and promised I would never take hiking boots on the Camino again, but here I am.. I'm planning my April Camino 2016 and I intend to take those same dreaded hiking boots with me.
I figured out the problem was not the boot, but the socks. Now I have found suitable socks to wear with the boots and I've been completely blister free on my recent walks. I can't afford new hiking shoes so I'll go with the boots. They are a bit heavy, so not ideal, but they keep my blisters away and my feet dry. So I'm happy with them.
Did you ask the salesman if he has ever walked 20 km/day for 3 days in a row?This year I bought new boots! Two sizes smaller on advice from the salesman. He said stop the slippage, go snug.
I wore Merrell boots and was very happy;
2 brands to look into."Aye, there's the rub!" -- Prince Hamlet
My wife swears by her Merrills, while I cannot find any that will fit my wide, duck-like feet. And believe me, I have looked high and low, far and wide, etc. Even their "wide-width" shoes/boots have toe caps that are far too narrow.
New Balance makes shoes in wide, extra wide and super wide(up to EEE widths) so you may want to look into their walking shoes. I've owned them in the past, they are very comfortable.
Both can be a bit hard to find if you are not in a more populous area, but both can be mail ordered.
Have you looked at the Skechers GoTrail Ultra?Now I'm wearing Skechers shoes, and really like them.
Have you looked at the Skechers GoTrail Ultra?
Yup. Wore 'em for years until other shoemakers caught on and increased my choices. Now I'm wearing Skechers shoes, and really like them. I particularly like their relatively thick soles; great for walking on rough/uneven or hot surfaces. Skechers shoes carried me all over Ireland, southern Spain, and many places here in the US of A. In May they're going to carry me through portions of Germany, Austria, Hungary and the Czech Republic.
I think that greater Los(t) Angeles may qualify as a "more populous area", don't you?
Now, with that said, I Googled Altra shoes. The 'one width' thing has me and my duck-feet concerned. I'll have to find a place where I can actually try them on.
While I am a 'boot guy' I have to be honest with you and say that boots on the Camino are overkill. I wore LaSportiva mid-boots, which are really a hiking shoe with a foam collar that wraps around the ankle. They were more than enough and the 'low' version of the same hiking shoe would have been plenty. I see no reason to wear a boot on the Camino. I had originally planned to wear a pair of lightweight Zamberlain Crosser 230GTX hiking boots (sort of a boot-shoe hybrid) but am glad I went with more of a shoe.
I have a pair of the Lone Peak and they are amazingly comfortable.The Altras have a very wide toe box. REI has them. The Lone Peak trail shoes are even wider than the other models.
I have read a lot of conflicting information - some say a good pair of hiking boots is required, especially if you are going in the Winter or Spring. Other sites say that hiking boots are overkill and that hiking shoes, or even a good pair of running shoes are sufficient. What do you think :?:
We are all different. I walked the Frances in early spring ie. 2 April from SJPdP in non-gortex trail runners and survived snow and rain to tell the tale. No blisters and no other foot problems. Would definitely wear the same again if walking at the same time. If I am ever lucky enough to walk it winter I would wear gortex trail runners. As I said, we are all different. Keep in mind too that trail runners have evolved beyond all imagination not only since this thread was started but in the last few years since I started wearing them. Anyone who has worn boots for years might want do some experimenting. Maybe worth a try?Depends on the Camino route you're going to do. For example, if you do the french way, hiking boots for winter and spring are a must, weather tends to be cold and possible rain. Then again, if you do the portguese way, weather is hotter so running shoes or hiking shoes would do.
Oh yes! In autumn 2015 walked the CF in trail runners while my sister and her husband walked in boots. I never got a blister. My sister got so many blisters she had to dump the boots and finish the walk in sandals bought along the way which she loved. Her husband absolutely convinced boots were essential wear refused to buy sandals and ended up walking in his crocs which were his evening wear.Topazy, I wore sandals both times I walked the Camino and never "bruised" my feet. Waterproof boots - even Goretex - seems like a good recipe for blisters to me. I know some people swear by boots on the Camino, but I remember coming into Zubiri and seeing the little sports store there full of pilgrims trading in their boots for lightweight shoes. Really, the only good advice is to train before you leave - walk a long ways every day - in the shoes, boots or sandals you intend to wear on the Camino and find out if they work for you. Otherwise, don't listen to anybody, including me, about what will work for you. For good advice about blisters and other foot problems, I do recommend www.fixingyourfeet.com . This guy knows what he's talking about.
Oh I don't disagree but I see lots of people say you need to wear boots or you shouldn't wear trail runners or running shoes are all you need ... my point is that there are all sorts of issues with posts like these that offer only partial advice.I don't think most of the problems are brand/model specific. Fit is by far the most important factor. In fact I think people get hung up on deciding they need a certain shoe or certain features and then they don't pay enough attention to how they feel. ...
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?