I cut and pasted the CSJ Eric Walker guide book - literally!. I cut out and dipsosed of all the bike directions (irrelevant to me) and reduced the whole guide by about 10 pages. By cutting the bike info out I found it quite easy to read, and follow, and also had some of the history bits to read as well. It was a fiddle with photo copying etc, but I found it worth while. Others I know didn't bother with his guide, but I am glad I had my version of it on hand.
A lot of people criticise the various guide books, yet they seem to fail to take into account the fact that at any time there are factors that will make the information they contain incorrect. A classic example of this is when I left Toulouse. On my first day out I got to the small town of Pibrac and turned left at the Post office as directed. Fortunately my sense of direction had kicked in (even though I was in the northern hemisphere) and I found I was going in the wrong direction. Even though I had retraced my steps to try and sort out where I was going wrong, I was unable to do so - there were no signs anywhere that I could find either. It was only some time later, when talking with a local, that I found out that the Post Office had moved around the corner and across the road, and that when I went to where the PO HAD BEEN - there were the signs! Incidences like this are not the fault of the guide writers and we pilgrims should stop blaming them for something that they have no control over.
cheers, Janet