Remove ads on the forum by becoming a donating member. More here. |
---|
The point here is that the rules are clear, but compliance is not always assured. That makes it very important for each individual to check things out and decide whether he or she wants to take whatever risks are posed.Better just to adjust to the rules.
Did you raise the issue of emergency exits with the managers/owners of the Casa de la Trinidad albergue? What did they say? Are there really no exits elsewhere other than the main entry?Stayed at casa de Trinidad convent in Laredo. Good albergue with most rooms only 2 or 3 beds but....they have a 10pm curfew. Most restaurants don't open until 9pm so it is a bit rushed. Four of us got back from food and beer at 2245. The cunning plan was another pilgrim inside ready to open the door. Unfortunately they actually lock the gate with a padlock![...]Seems a bit unsafe to lock people in if you needed an ambulance or to escape a fire. Do they not have regulations in Spain?
The nuns lock the outer gates at the street, but not the door up the steps into the convent, right? At least that was the case when I stayed in 2019, and I was told they would be locked. Nobody was locked inside the building itself.Four of us got back from food and beer at 2245. The cunning plan was another pilgrim inside ready to open the door. Unfortunately they actually lock the gate with a padlock!
In most countries it would be illegal and would be heavily fined. If it really is the case, I believe it‘s irresponsible to leave it as personal responsibility and comfort level.We have had several threads on this topic, and the most recent one is here. The consensus is that fire regulations do require that people have access to a fire exit. These regulations may either be honored in the breach or may not apply to some of these old buildings. In any case, pilgrims should be aware that in some cases they will be locked inside at night.
The bottom line is that this is an issue that seems to be up to the individual pilgrim to assess upon arrival. Ask about fire exits. If you don’t like the response, you can vote with your feet. I don’t mean to trivialize this, because it is an extremely serious issue, but the bottom line is that the wide variation in practice leaves it as an issue of personal responsibility and comfort level.
In most countries it would be illegal and would be heavily fined. If it really is the case, I believe it‘s irresponsible to leave it as personal responsibility and comfort level.
If you read the previous, recent thread I have linked to on the third post in this thread, you may understand the situation better. Spanish law requires emergency exits. That means that the situation on the ground in Spain may violate applicable regional, national or local regulations. If you arrive at a place that does not provide emergency exits, you can decide there whether to find out how to lodge a complaint or to go elsewhere. Some of the posts in that earlier thread pointed out that there are in fact places where the doors are locked but emergency exits exist. We cannot do a survey of all albergues, so the best advice is to pay attention when you arrive at an albergue.In most countries it would be illegal and would be heavily fined. If it really is the case, I believe it‘s irresponsible to leave it as personal responsibility and comfort level.
One can also file a complaint via an hoja de reclamaciones which every lodging establishment is required to provide.If you read the previous, recent thread I have linked to on the third post in this thread, you may understand the situation better. Spanish law requires emergency exits. That means that the situation on the ground in Spain may violate applicable regional, national or local regulations. If you arrive at a place that does not provide emergency exits, you can decide there whether to find out how to lodge a complaint or to go elsewhere. Some of the posts in that earlier thread pointed out that there are in fact places where the doors are locked but emergency exits exist. We cannot do a survey of all albergues, so the best advice is to pay attention when you arrive at an albergue.
I think that the forum provides a good service when pilgrims are encouraged to scope out the situation upon arrival, because it is something that many of us would not have considered doing until forum members alerted us to the situation.
I wonder if donativos are exempt.I never remember having one of these in a donativo where I have worked. We did have a journal book where people left notes about their stay, but that was it.
Well, when you are hosting people commercially, there are rules applied.Well it is as it is. If someone does not feel comfortable with this they can always choose a private place.
And as already written above : you can always take it up with the hospi/ owner " on the ground ".
Life is a risk.
Seen in Sevilla years ago...
View attachment 124975
I must say that I agree with you: In a commercial establishment in Spain, I would expect that there are emergency exits and it would not occur to me to check before I stay there. I guess one always ought to check once you are in your room but I admit that I rarely do.When you are hosting people commercially, there are rules applied. And to be honest I wouldn’t think about asking, but take for granted that general rules/laws where followed for a place with public access. There could be a variety of reasons why people would be able to get out. And it Is not that I approve of people not act according to the rules of the establishment, but fire exits are there for a reason, and should be easy accessible.
No they are not, the CSJ albergue in Miraz had an issue a few years ago when a pilgrim asked to see their book/ form, the hospitaleros didn't know what they were, "the pilgrim" went to the police and they turned up asking to see the form. CSJ at the time had to question themselves was it worth keeping the Donativo open.I wonder if donativos are exempt.
I guess that this was not about emergency exists? We may be getting into the "ungrateful pilgrim" topic. Complaining about food, bed bugs, opening hours or whatever is one thing. Being concerned about emergency exits is another thing altogether."the pilgrim" went to the police and they turned up asking to see the form. CSJ at the time had to question themselves was it worth keeping the Donativo open.
I think we are going back 9 or 10 years, maybe there is a thread about it somewhere, where do I dig this up? I think CSJ has an arrangement with the Diocese in Friol about the building and it's ownership, rent etc.I guess that this was not about emergency exists? We may be getting into the "ungrateful pilgrim" topic. Complaining about food, bed bugs or whatever is one thing. Being concerned about emergency exits is another thing.
As to donativo albergues and similar .... in many cases, proprietor or volunteers are often staying inside and sleeping inside. Even if there is only one exit and it is locked during the night and the key is out of sight and out of reach of the pilgrims and there are no windows to escape ... wouldn't it be a bit far fetched to think that everyone who knows where the keys are will be incapacitated in an emergency, mobile phones will not work to call 112 and so on ...? Perhaps, if one indulges in such doomsday scenarios, one should not stay at Camino albergues.
Do you happen to know about the emergency exit situation at the CSJ albergue in Miraz and whether or not national or regional regulations about the prevention and management of fire incidents apply to them or not? Is it privately owned, or owned by the town of Miraz or the parrish?
I now see that there is a Twitter feed @refugiodemiraz although it is defunct, the last tweet is from 2014. However, it does say that the albergue de peregrinos [is] run by the Confraternity of Saint James. The building is the former Rectoral and is still owned by the Diocese of Lugo.I think CSJ has an arrangement with the Diocese in Friol about the building and it's ownership, rent etc.
There is a thread from 2014 where there are complaints about the late opening hours (4 pm) of Miraz from 2014 but there is another more interesting thread from 2005 where they announce that they have an agreement to use the ancient refectory of Miraz as an albergue and they say that they need to raise £100,000 to kick-start restoration and finance the initial running costs. Wow.maybe there is a thread about it somewhere, where do I dig this up
They questioned keeping the albergue open because they couldn't find the complaints book??No they are not, the CSJ albergue in Miraz had an issue a few years ago when a pilgrim asked to see their book/ form, the hospitaleros didn't know what they were, "the pilgrim" went to the police and they turned up asking to see the form. CSJ at the time had to question themselves was it worth keeping the Donativo open.
Yes, the story of the CSJ albergues at Rabanal and Miraz is pretty epic. Huge amounts of funds have been raised through the years by the membership and hundreds of people, primarily from English-speaking countries, have volunteered there as hospitalera/os. Both albergues have provided a brilliant service over the years.There is a thread from 2014 where there are complaints about the late opening hours (4 pm) of Miraz from 2014 but there is another more interesting thread from 2005 where they announce that they have an agreement to use the ancient refectory of Miraz as an albergue and they say that they need to raise £100,000 to kick-start restoration and finance the initial running costs. Wow.
Stayed at casa de Trinidad convent in Laredo. Good albergue with most rooms only 2 or 3 beds but....they have a 10pm curfew. Most restaurants don't open until 9pm so it is a bit rushed.
Four of us got back from food and beer at 2245. The cunning plan was another pilgrim inside ready to open the door. Unfortunately they actually lock the gate with a padlock!
In this case 3 pilgrims scaled the 3m fence. I could not but fortunately found a spare bed. So in this case just another story from the Camino
I think you may have misunderstood the reason for my question. This would not be first case where people wrongly claim that there were no emergency exits. I'm merely curious about this particular case.I think it's been answered clearly. There ARE fire regulations in Spain. They might not meet YOUR fire regulation standards, but nobody asked us. If you don't like what you see, go some other place that meets your standards.
Thank you, we appreciate the information, as many may not know about curfews or lock ins and after a long day walking, possibly getting in later than expected, it's good to know to stop ahead of time for refreshments & food in order to respect albergue owners rules. thank you for sharing. Buen Camino~Stayed at casa de Trinidad convent in Laredo. Good albergue with most rooms only 2 or 3 beds but....they have a 10pm curfew. Most restaurants don't open until 9pm so it is a bit rushed.
Four of us got back from food and beer at 2245. The cunning plan was another pilgrim inside ready to open the door. Unfortunately they actually lock the gate with a padlock!
In this case 3 pilgrims scaled the 3m fence. I could not but fortunately found a spare bed. So in this case just another story from the Camino
However it might not be a happy ending. Seems a bit unsafe to lock people in if you needed an ambulance or to escape a fire. Do they not have regulations in Spain?
View attachment 124959
Certainly the refugio at Rabanal is owned by the bishopric - of Bierzo IIRC not Astorga - and not by the CSJ.I think we are going back 9 or 10 years, maybe there is a thread about it somewhere, where do I dig this up? I think CSJ has an arrangement with the Diocese in Friol about the building and it's ownership, rent etc.
I think it is “concerning” that padlocks are used, this is in contravention of Fire Regs. How do you know how long it took to be served but jump to judgement. Walk your own Camino was the motto I thought.That’s been a perennial discussion topic on this forum - we don’t need to rehash the legalities and morality of locked albergues yet again. It is concerning, though, that you purposefully chose to go against the albergue policy in order to have a few beers….
I would remind us all that several months ago the Refugio in LaFaba reportedly burnt down from an electrical fire! Many buildings are old. And It doesn’t matter if you are staying in a humble donativo or a Parador!However, as to donativo albergues and similar .... in many cases, proprietor or volunteers are often staying inside and sleeping inside. Even if there is only one exit and it is locked during the night and the key is out of sight and out of reach of the pilgrims and there are no windows to escape ... wouldn't it be a bit far fetched to think that everyone who knows where the keys are will be incapacitated in an emergency, mobile phones will not work to call 112, there are no fire extinguishers and so on ...? Perhaps, if one indulges in such doomsday scenarios, one should not stay at Camino albergues.
Your opening title made me curious. Here is a segment I found in the MerriamWebster site:Stayed at casa de Trinidad convent in Laredo. Good albergue with most rooms only 2 or 3 beds but....they have a 10pm curfew. Most restaurants don't open until 9pm so it is a bit rushed.
Four of us got back from food and beer at 2245. The cunning plan was another pilgrim inside ready to open the door. Unfortunately they actually lock the gate with a padlock!
In this case 3 pilgrims scaled the 3m fence. I could not but fortunately found a spare bed. So in this case just another story from the Camino
However it might not be a happy ending. Seems a bit unsafe to lock people in if you needed an ambulance or to escape a fire. Do they not have regulations in Spain?
View attachment 124959
You list an impressive number of Caminos under your avatar. I’m just curious: during all this time, did it ever happen that a Camino accommodation did not meet emergency plan requirements and you left because of it? If so, did you ask? It would certainly be useful in the interest of other pilgrims to raise the issue and to raise awareness of a proprietor/manager IF there is such an apparent need.The suggestions offered should take you no more than a couple of minutes of your time when you first arrive! If you can not exit a building within 60 seconds without assistance do not stay there!
The sisters, the Monjas Trinitarias de Laredo, who offer accommodation to pilgrims and other tourists in their Casa maintain a Facebook group with dozens of cheerful photos that makes me want to stay there. Here's a view of the cloister and of the back of the building. It clearly has more than one single door.It has a cloister. It has a huge garden/park area at the back and also a large green area on at least one side.
I was wondering the same thing about safety as I was reading this. I was based at the albergue in Salamanca in 2009, the first time I volunteered for hospitalero duty and the prior Hospitaleros had instructed me specifically not to lock the doors from the inside per fire, health/safety regulations. I would think that whoever is padlocking that particular albergue is doing so at risk of endangering others. Just my opinion…Stayed at casa de Trinidad convent in Laredo. Good albergue with most rooms only 2 or 3 beds but....they have a 10pm curfew. Most restaurants don't open until 9pm so it is a bit rushed.
Four of us got back from food and beer at 2245. The cunning plan was another pilgrim inside ready to open the door. Unfortunately they actually lock the gate with a padlock!
In this case 3 pilgrims scaled the 3m fence. I could not but fortunately found a spare bed. So in this case just another story from the Camino
However it might not be a happy ending. Seems a bit unsafe to lock people in if you needed an ambulance or to escape a fire. Do they not have regulations in Spain?
View attachment 124959
Thanks for pointing this out as someone who actually knows this albergue in Laredo, and also: I, too, enjoyed reading your description at the end of your post. I like to stay in monasteries and other old buildings, when it is a "working" convent with a hospederia but also when it is a converted historic building.So I can't definitively answer if there were other exits accessible to pilgrims, just that the door leading out into the stepped courtyard wasn't locked from inside, but the gates at the bottom onto the street, were.
Well, not going to that place. Thanks for the heads up. Clearly a bad policy that doesn’t need to be rewarded.Stayed at casa de Trinidad convent in Laredo. Good albergue with most rooms only 2 or 3 beds but....they have a 10pm curfew. Most restaurants don't open until 9pm so it is a bit rushed.
Four of us got back from food and beer at 2245. The cunning plan was another pilgrim inside ready to open the door. Unfortunately they actually lock the gate with a padlock!
In this case 3 pilgrims scaled the 3m fence. I could not but fortunately found a spare bed. So in this case just another story from the Camino
However it might not be a happy ending. Seems a bit unsafe to lock people in if you needed an ambulance or to escape a fire. Do they not have regulations in Spain?
View attachment 124959
…or go to the door that leads to the choir loft inside the church and go down the stairs there (straight ahead and to the right of memory is serving me correctly) and go through the church entrance doors. That is, if it’s not the church that’s on fire!One place that instantly comes to mind about escaping from a fire would be the much loved Granon. The only way out is a narrow set of winding stairs or jumping out a window.
No indeed, lots of accommodation choices in and around Laredo that might better suit your standards and deserve your business. And while you're relaxing in one of them, you might have the time to take a few minutes and read the entire thread..Well, not going to that place. Thanks for the heads up. Clearly a bad policy that doesn’t need to be rewarded.
But the door is never locked there...always open and welcoming for all.One place that instantly comes to mind about escaping from a fire would be the much loved Granon. The only way out is a narrow set of winding stairs or jumping out a window.
I just did. What was it supposed to gather from it? I’m sure I’m missing something. Anyway, Seems like a bad practice to lock people in. Or at least something I’d be pretty uncomfortable with. Because of that I will seek locations that don’t use this practice.No indeed, lots of accommodation choices in and around Laredo that might better suit your standards and deserve your business. And while you're relaxing in one of them, you might have the time to take a few minutes and read the entire thread..
I'm sure you are too, you and many others. Buenas Noches, Buen Camino..I’m sure I’m missing something.
No, Katharina, here in Spain, I have not had this experience. And I will never have it again anywhere. I am a planner, and when I travel, I careful review anywhere we decide to stay at. I review environmental factors such as carpeting that might trigger allergic reactions, cleanliness, bed bug reports, plumbing issues, as well as safety features. Reviewing several accommodation websites sites, as well as pictures of the place, on the specific accommodation site for things such as windows, including windows big enough to get out of in a an emergency in the room we might stay in is a must for me. In addition, we ask for rooms on lower or entrance levels, when booking. When we arrive we check stair access and how to exit the building from doors and our room window(s). And we make sure the window opens. We review the emergency exit plan, if one is in the room. All of this takes only a couple of minutes. But, God forbid, a fire takes place we have a better chance of survival.You list an impressive number of Caminos under your avatar. I’m just curious: during all this time, did it ever happen that a Camino accommodation did not meet emergency plan requirements and you left because of it? If so, did you ask? It would certainly be useful in the interest of other pilgrims to raise the issue and to raise awareness of a proprietor/manager IF there is such an apparent need.
I have not stayed at the Laredo convent. Early in this thread, a forum member who did stay there wrote that there ARE other exits than the main entry leading to the street. The convent appears to be a large complex. It has a cloister. It has a huge garden/park area at the back and also a large green area on at least one side. I am still curious to know whether there is really no other way out in cases where there is a NEED to get out and not a WANT to get out onto the street at the front or to get IN from the street at the front during night-time when other pilgrims rest and sleep.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?