Doug said
“First, there are some who claim that wearing the straps correctly is more dangerous than not wearing the straps at all. Their 'evidence', if they suggest there is any, is anecdotal, and they have never been able to point to anything like reported walking related accident or injury statistics that bear out their assertions. At that point, I take the view that their objections are matters of personal preference, not rational objective decision making, and leave them to it.”
I do not recall such a discussion but I would caution those using straps to be careful on terrain that is less stable....downhills, rocky areas where poles can get stuck in crevices, narrow paths-especially near cliffs, and wet or muddy terrain where poles can slip or get stuck in mud.
My and others experiences are important information. I do believe that there are sufficient reports to suggest caution with regards to the use of straps.
I read this on another blog and I thought it was worth posting. The responder. Rick, is commenting on the use of Hiking pole straps.
“I used to always use them, and even fell with them on a couple of times – breaking a pole as a result one time. Then I started finding out about just how many dislocated shoulders, etc. have been caused by that. So now I don’t use them, even though I think they make the poles easier to use. “
Here is another hiker reporting what happened to him .while hiking. Alansloman.blogspot.com
...” after the climb up Dearg Allt and with Kinbreack within eyeshot, disaster struck! One leg slid about four feet down the slithery oozing hillside while one trekking pole planted itself firmly in the one solid bit of land in the whole of Scotland. With my arm caught in the wrist loop, the rest of me plummeted ground-wards, twisting under the weight of my pack. Explosions seemed to go off in my arm on the way down until I ended up face down in the bog. I lay there for a moment checking myself over. Mike unfastened my pack and I sat there, my mind totally numb as my arm screamed at me. I had no idea what I had done but I could not move it. After a while I limped into Kinbreack, one of my titanium poles completely buckled.”
Here is another report
I am one who has been injured by using straps. A couple Winters ago I was coming down the Owlshead Brutus bushwack. I lost traction on a steep section, and fell forward. My hiking pole/basket snagged a tree. The strap kept my hand attached to the pole. My arm snapped back as I fell forward, and ripped my bicep tendon.
So, no more straps on the downhills…..
My personal recommendation is not to keep your wrists in the poles when you are on uneven terrain, on narrow paths or near crevices where the poles can get caught. A few specific places, I would caution others about using the straps would be coming down to Roncevalles on the steep path, coming down from Alto del Perdon and coming from El Acebo to Molinesca. Also use caution when on any rocky path...going uphill where the poles can get caught in the rocks...