I think each type of establishment has advantages and disadvantages so take into consideration the whole package. Is there a private room, private bath, kitchen for pilgrim use, communal meal, proximity to a store, proximity to a bar, pillows, sheets, bath towels, common area, wifi, laundry area for hand washing, laundry machine, clothes drying area, closeness of beds, and costs. Think about what else you find essential as you look for private rooms and baths. We stayed in a private room with bath this year with towels, sheets, and pillows, but no kitchen or proximity to a store or bar so it was a long walk after a long day to get food and drink. Take in the whole picture if you can.