Cycling vs walking?
I've not walked the camino but I cycled Frances and Finnistere in 2015. I did consider walking so you might be interested in my reasons for cycling.
I live in the Irish midlands. An archaeological dig of a monastic graveyard in a nearby town, Mullingar turned up two skeletons who had been buried with scallop shells. A reasonable assumption is that they were two monks who had made the pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostelo in the middle ages. Aha, I've always wanted to acquire some grave goods, this sounds like a fun thing to do!
To mark the end of fifty years of working life I wanted to do my own version of the camino. I decided it would have to be human powered, as far as possible, and start from Ireland. Walking from Ireland, down west France and across Spain would take me a minimum of 70 days and, for family reasons I could not get away for that long. So Leatherlugs the bike, named after a beloved childhood donkey, and I decided to cycle.
From home to Cork, ferry to Roscoff, across Brittany and the Vendee to La Rochelle. At that stage we decided we wanted to be in Spain so we took the train to Dax and started again on
camino Frances. Then to Santiago de Compostello and Finistere. We took the bus back to Santander and the ferry back to the UK. A wonderful, magical trip that I'm still trying to understand.
My experience of cycling the camino is that it's a more solitary occupation than walking. There were very few cyclists when I was there in May. That's if you don't count the Spanish mountain bikers who zipped past me in a flash of lycra!
Leatherlugs can do three or four times the speed of the walkers so that meant meeting different people every night in the albergues.
As a result you don't get to be a part of the 'camino families' that seem to develop among the walkers.Evening conversations were always wonderful but there were many people that I'd have loved to continue the conversation with on the following day. Yet I also cherish the solitary days on the bike on the mesata which gave the prefect time to think.
I'm planning to return to cycle Frances and Del Norte this year with a friend. I've no doubt it will be different but every bit as great.
I envy the walkers their communities of the camino and will definitely walk it someday soon.
So, cycle or walk? I dunno!