I walked my first camino back in 2000 when the only luggage transport was from Villafranca to O’Cebreiro and there were few private albergues so I am somewhat old school in my thoughts on the camino so my thinking is that if you can afford to have your luggage transported, you should be able to afford a private albergue.
But rather than rely on my own feelings, I just checked the website of the Spanish Federación Española de Asociaciones de Amigos del
Camino de Santiago and the Google translation concurs with my thinking, “since the shelters will be destined for individual pilgrims who have to carry their luggage with them.” This is an explanation of why some of the luggage transport services arrange pick-up and drop-off at bars and the similar places. so if you are planning on using a munincipal albergue, you might want to reconsider the usage of a transport service.
One of the things I noticed on my last camino was that a lot of the people carrying backpacks were older. In the group I was walking with, the three of us that carried our backpacks were also the three oldest, and all in our 60’s. i Am planning on walking my next camino in 2025 to celebrate 25 years after my first, and even though I will be in my 70’s, I plan to carry a backpack.
I walked my first Camino, and had the intention of carrying my backpack all the way. However, right at the half-way point, I injured myself. In order to finish my Camino, I had to limit myself to 10km a day, and I ended up sending my backpack on as well. When I got home, I went to the doctor, and from an MRI, I was diagnosed with partial-thickness tears in the peroneal tendons in both of my feet. Surgery was not recommended, but this kind of injury means you have to be more careful.
On my second Camino, I had the same intention but already knew by Pamplona that carrying my pack was a pipe dream. Then, because even not carrying my pack was allowing me to do a decent (slightly below average to average) amount of Km a day, I ended up renting a bicycle until Astorga, then going back to walking and sending my pack on.
This coming Camino, I have been trying to train with my pack fully loaded (23 lbs including 2.5 liters of water), and have come to the conclusion that, if I carry my pack, my body can handle 15km a day--this is with taped feet and ice afterward. I can stretch it to 20km, but if I do so, I'm toast, and my feet hurt so much that even after sleeping, they still ache. This is a recipe for injury if I'm doing this day after day, and it is not possible to walk the Camino Portuguese from Lisbon with these km restrictions. Before you ask, I'm wearing good hiking boots that fit me well. I've done everything I can to lower my pack weight, and since this is my 3rd rodeo, I have a good idea of what gear does and doesn't work for me.
So, reluctantly, I've changed my plans from walking from Lisbon to walking from Porto so that I can make use of pack carrying services. I'm 45, and I was 37 and 40 for my other two Caminos.
If I could walk the Camino and carry my own backpack, I would. prior injury precludes that, so I'm incredibly thankful for the fact that there are pack carrying services available. I look like a healthy middle-aged woman, but that is misleading when it comes to my feet and my prior injuries. I'm glad that you can carry your pack, but please don't pass judgment on people who can't.
Ruth