I agree with you 100%. Millions of pilgrims visit dozens of Christian shrines every year without having to walk there. The 100km rule introduced by the cathedral in the 1990s created huge crowds walking from Sarria and accusations of cheating...
Personally I would argue that anyone who flies to SdC and visits the cathedral and the tomb of the Apostle in the right spirit is making a pilgrimage to Santiago. 30 years ago the cathedral made the decision to make receiving a Compostela...
In the early Middle Ages the 30 December was St James’ Feast day, based on the old Hispanic (Mozarabic) rite.
In the 11th century King Alfonso VI abolished the Hispanic rite in favour of the Roman rite and 25 July became the principal feast day...
In 2013 an 2014 I led Slow Camino groups from Sarria and from Ferrol respectively. The oldest in our groups was a man of 89 and then 90. He was amazing. We sent packs ahead and stayed in private rooms.
-Camino Frances (Santiago de Compostela ~ Obanos)
-Camino Aragones =(Spain, Obanos ~ Col du Somport), 164.3 km
-GR 653(Camino Arles) = ( Col du Somport ~ Arles), 802 km
-GR 653A (Arles ~ Menton), 394 km
-Via della Costa = (Menton ~Genoa ~La...
You won't qualify for a Compostela if you don't walk to the cathedral. As the Cathedral website says, it's not about the walking, it's about arriving at the Cathedral and reveering the relics of the Saint is the goal.
This site is run by Ivar at in Santiago de Compostela.
This site participates in the Amazon Affiliate program, designed to provide a means for Ivar to earn fees by linking to Amazon